McDonald Catherine C, Kandadai Venk, Loeb Helen, Seacrist Thomas, Lee Yi-Ching, Bonfiglio Dana, Fisher Donald L, Winston Flaura K
University of Pennsylvania, School of Nursing, Claire Fagin Hall, 418 Curie Boulevard, 414, Philadelphia, PA 19104-4217, .
The Center for Injury Research and Prevention, The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, 3535 Market St, Suite 1150, Philadelphia, PA 19104, .
Transp Res Rec. 2015;2516:15-21. doi: 10.3141/2516-03.
Collisions at left turn intersections are among the most prevalent types of teen driver serious crashes, with inadequate surveillance as a key factor. Risk awareness perception training (RAPT) has shown effectiveness in improving hazard anticipation for latent hazards. The goal of this study was to determine if RAPT version 3 (RAPT-3) improved intersection turning behaviors among novice teen drivers when the hazards were not latent and frequent glancing to multiple locations at the intersection was needed. Teens aged 16-18 with ≤180 days of licensure were randomly assigned to: 1) an intervention group (n=18) that received RAPT-3 (Trained); or 2) a control group (n=19) that received no training (Untrained). Both groups completed RAPT-3 Baseline Assessment and the Trained group completed RAPT-3 Training and RAPT-3 Post Assessment. Training effects were evaluated on a driving simulator. Simulator ( errors and ) and eye tracker ( errors) metrics from six left-turn stop sign controlled intersections in the Simulated Driving Assessment (SDA) were analyzed. The Trained group scored significantly higher in RAPT-3 Post Assessment than RAPT-3 Baseline Assessment (p< 0.0001). There were no significant differences in either and errors or among Trained and Untrained teens in the SDA. Though Trained teens learned about hazard anticipation related to latent hazards, learning did not translate to performance differences in left-turn stop sign controlled intersections where the hazards were not latent. Our findings point to further research to better understand the challenges teens have with left turn intersections.
左转路口的碰撞事故是青少年驾驶员严重车祸中最常见的类型之一,其中监控不足是一个关键因素。风险意识感知训练(RAPT)已显示出在提高对潜在危险的危险预判方面的有效性。本研究的目的是确定当危险并非潜在且需要频繁扫视路口多个位置时,RAPT第3版(RAPT-3)是否能改善新手青少年驾驶员在路口转弯时的行为。16至18岁、领证时间≤180天的青少年被随机分为:1)干预组(n = 18),接受RAPT-3训练(受过训练);或2)对照组(n = 19),不接受训练(未受过训练)。两组都完成了RAPT-3基线评估,干预组完成了RAPT-3训练和RAPT-3后评估。在驾驶模拟器上评估训练效果。分析了模拟驾驶评估(SDA)中六个设有停车标志的左转路口的模拟器(误差和 )以及眼动仪(误差)指标。干预组在RAPT-3后评估中的得分显著高于RAPT-3基线评估(p < 0.0001)。在SDA中,受过训练和未受过训练的青少年在 误差和 或 方面均无显著差异。尽管受过训练的青少年了解了与潜在危险相关的危险预判,但这种学习并没有转化为在危险并非潜在的设有停车标志的左转路口的性能差异。我们的研究结果表明需要进一步研究,以更好地理解青少年在左转路口面临的挑战。