Kouyoumdjian Fiona G, Schuler Andrée, McIsaac Kathryn E, Pivnick Lucie, Matheson Flora I, Brown Glenn, Kiefer Lori, Silva Diego, Hwang Stephen W
Centre for Research on Inner City Health, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Centre for Research on Inner City Health, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Dalla Lana School of Public Health, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
BMJ Open. 2016 Jan 14;6(1):e010125. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010125.
A large number of Canadians spend time in correctional facilities each year, and they are likely to have poor health compared to the general population. Relatively little health research has been conducted in Canada with a focus on people who experience detention or incarceration. We aimed to conduct a Delphi process with key stakeholders to define priorities for research in prison health in Canada for the next 10 years.
We conducted a Delphi process using an online survey with two rounds in 2014 and 2015.
We invited key stakeholders in prison health research in Canada to participate, which we defined as persons who had published research on prison health in Canada since 1994 and persons in the investigators' professional networks. We invited 143 persons to participate in the first round and 59 participated. We invited 137 persons to participate in the second round and 67 participated.
Participants suggested topics in the first round, and these topics were collated by investigators. We measured the level of agreement among participants that each collated topic was a priority for prison health research in Canada for the next 10 years, and defined priorities based on the level of agreement.
In the first round, participants suggested 71 topics. In the second round, consensus was achieved that a large number of suggested topics were research priorities. Top priorities were diversion and alternatives to incarceration, social and community re-integration, creating healthy environments in prisons, healthcare in custody, continuity of healthcare, substance use disorders and the health of Aboriginal persons in custody.
Generated in an inclusive and systematic process, these findings should inform future research efforts to improve the health and healthcare of people who experience detention and incarceration in Canada.
每年有大量加拿大人在惩教机构中度过,与普通人群相比,他们的健康状况可能较差。在加拿大,针对经历拘留或监禁的人群开展的健康研究相对较少。我们旨在与关键利益相关者进行德尔菲法流程,以确定加拿大未来10年监狱健康研究的优先事项。
我们在2014年和2015年通过在线调查进行了两轮德尔菲法流程。
我们邀请了加拿大监狱健康研究的关键利益相关者参与,我们将其定义为自1994年以来在加拿大发表过监狱健康研究的人员以及研究人员专业网络中的人员。我们邀请了143人参与第一轮,59人参与。我们邀请了137人参与第二轮,67人参与。
参与者在第一轮中提出主题,研究人员对这些主题进行整理。我们衡量了参与者对每个整理后的主题是加拿大未来10年监狱健康研究优先事项的认同程度,并根据认同程度确定优先事项。
在第一轮中,参与者提出了71个主题。在第二轮中,达成共识的是大量提出的主题是研究优先事项。首要优先事项是监禁的替代措施和转移、社会和社区重新融入、在监狱中营造健康环境、拘留期间的医疗保健、医疗保健的连续性、物质使用障碍以及被拘留原住民的健康。
这些结果是通过一个包容且系统的过程产生的,应为未来改善加拿大经历拘留和监禁人员的健康及医疗保健的研究工作提供信息。