Hillman Alexandra
School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University , 10 Museum Place, Cathays, Cardiff CF10 3BG, UK . E-mail:
Soc Theory Health. 2016 Feb;14(1):66-87. doi: 10.1057/sth.2015.10. Epub 2015 Jun 3.
This article draws on concepts of morality and demoralisation to understand the problematic nature of relationships between staff and patients in public health services. The article uses data from a case study of a UK hospital Emergency Department to show how staff are tasked with the responsibility of treating and caring for patients, while at the same time their actions are shaped by the institutional concerns of accountability and resource management. The data extracts illustrate how such competing agendas create a tension for staff to manage and suggests that, as a consequence of this tension, staff participate in processes of 'effacement' that limit the presence of patients and families as a moral demand. The analysis from the Emergency Department case study suggests that demoralisation is an increasingly important lens through which to understand health-care institutions, where contemporary organisational cultures challenge the ethical quality of human interaction.
本文借鉴道德与士气低落的概念,以理解公共卫生服务中工作人员与患者关系的问题本质。本文利用英国一家医院急诊科的案例研究数据,展示了工作人员如何承担治疗和护理患者的责任,而与此同时,他们的行为又受到问责制和资源管理等机构问题的影响。数据摘录说明了这些相互冲突的议程如何给工作人员带来管理上的紧张局面,并表明,由于这种紧张局面,工作人员参与了“抹杀”过程,将患者和家属的在场限制为一种道德要求。急诊科案例研究的分析表明,士气低落是理解医疗机构日益重要的一个视角,在这些机构中,当代组织文化对人际互动的道德品质构成了挑战。