Sidney Kristi, Iyer Veena, Vora Kranti, Mavalankar Dileep, De Costa Ayesha
Public Health Sciences, Karolinska Institutet, Widerströmska, Tomtebodavägen 18A, plan 4, SE-171 77, Stockholm, Sweden.
Indian Institute of Public Health Gandhinagar, Public Health Foundation of India, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
J Health Popul Nutr. 2016 Jan 27;35:2. doi: 10.1186/s41043-016-0039-z.
The Chiranjeevi Yojana (CY) is a large public-private partnership program in Gujarat, India, under which the state pays private sector obstetricians to provide childbirth services to poor and tribal women. The CY was initiated statewide in 2007 because of the limited ability of the public health sector to provide emergency obstetric care and high out-of-pocket expenditures in the private sector (where most qualified obstetricians work), creating financial access barriers for poor women. Despite a million beneficiaries, there have been few reports studying CY, particularly the proportion of vulnerable women being covered, the expenditures they incur in connection with childbirth, and the level of subsidy provided to beneficiaries by the program.
Cross-sectional facility based the survey of participants in three districts of Gujarat in 2012-2013. Women were interviewed to elicit sociodemographic characteristics, out-of-pocket expenditures, and CY program details. Descriptive statistics, chi square, and a multivariable logistic regression were performed.
Of the 901 women surveyed in 129 facilities, 150 (16 %) were CY beneficiaries; 336 and 415 delivered in government and private facilities, respectively. Only 36 (24 %) of the 150 CY beneficiaries received a completely cashless delivery. Median out-of-pocket for vaginal/cesarean delivery among CY beneficiaries was $7/$71. The median degree of subsidy for women in CY who delivered vaginally/cesarean was 85/71 % compared to out-of-pocket expenditure of $44/$208 for vaginal/cesarean delivery paid by non-program beneficiaries in the private health sector.
CY beneficiaries experienced a substantially subsidized childbirth compared to women who delivered in non-accredited private facilities. However, despite the government's efforts at increasing access to delivery services for poor women in the private sector, uptake was low and very few women experienced a cashless delivery. While the long-term focus remains on strengthening the public sector's ability to provide emergency obstetric care, the CY program is a potential means by which the state can ensure its poor mothers have access to necessary care if uptake is increased.
“奇拉尼维计划”(CY)是印度古吉拉特邦一项大型公私合作项目,该邦向私立部门的产科医生支付费用,让其为贫困和部落妇女提供分娩服务。由于公共卫生部门提供紧急产科护理的能力有限,且私立部门(大多数合格产科医生工作的地方)自付费用高昂,给贫困妇女造成了经济获取障碍,CY于2007年在全州启动。尽管有百万受益者,但对CY进行研究的报告很少,尤其是关于弱势妇女的覆盖比例、她们分娩时产生的费用以及该项目向受益者提供的补贴水平。
2012 - 2013年在古吉拉特邦三个地区基于设施进行横断面调查。对妇女进行访谈,以获取社会人口学特征、自付费用和CY项目细节。进行描述性统计、卡方检验和多变量逻辑回归分析。
在129个设施中接受调查的901名妇女中,150名(16%)是CY受益者;分别有336名和415名在政府设施和私立设施分娩。150名CY受益者中只有36名(24%)实现了完全免费分娩。CY受益者阴道分娩/剖宫产的自付费用中位数分别为7美元/71美元。与私立卫生部门非项目受益者阴道分娩/剖宫产自付费用44美元/208美元相比,CY项目中阴道分娩/剖宫产妇女的补贴中位数比例为85%/71%。
与在未经认可的私立设施分娩的妇女相比,CY受益者分娩得到了大幅补贴。然而,尽管政府努力增加贫困妇女在私立部门获得分娩服务的机会,但参与率很低,很少有妇女实现免费分娩。虽然长期重点仍是加强公共部门提供紧急产科护理的能力,但如果提高参与率,CY项目是该邦确保贫困母亲能够获得必要护理的一种潜在手段。