Spies Cynthia, Seale Ielse, Botma Yvonne
School of Nursing, University of the Free State.
Curationis. 2015 Nov 20;38(2):1494. doi: 10.4102/curationis.v38i2.1494.
Most nurse educators regard students who enter postgraduate studies as adult learners capable of self-direction and independent learner behaviour. Therefore, a mismatch between the nurse educator's expectation of adult learners and actual adult learner conduct may result in disappointment and even frustration for both educator and learner.
This article is a report of a secondary analysis of data that were collected to explore the high-fidelity simulation learning experiences of a group of postgraduate nursing students.The secondary analysis was done to determine whether adult learners who bring professional knowledge and experience to a postgraduate learning environment displayed adult learner conduct as proposed by educational theorist Malcolm Knowles.
Using a qualitative descriptive research design, data were gathered from 18 postgraduate nursing students who participated in high-fidelity simulation in a nursing school at a higher education institution in South Africa. The nominal group technique was used to collect the students' ideas about improving their simulation learning experiences. A secondary qualitative analysis of the primary nominal group data was done.
Data either confirmed or belied adult learner behaviour. Although the findings suggested self-directed and independent learner behaviour, they also revealed behaviour evident of dependence on the educator.
Mature students have well established ways of thinking and doing that may hinder learning. Educators have to support adult learners in developing effective learning techniques in order to maximise the benefits of their experience and knowledge by fostering independence and self-direction.
大多数护理教育工作者认为进入研究生阶段学习的学生是能够自我引导和具备独立学习行为的成人学习者。因此,护理教育工作者对成人学习者的期望与成人学习者的实际行为之间的不匹配可能会导致教育工作者和学习者双方的失望甚至沮丧。
本文是对一组研究生护理学生的高保真模拟学习经历数据进行二次分析的报告。进行二次分析是为了确定那些将专业知识和经验带入研究生学习环境的成人学习者是否表现出教育理论家马尔科姆·诺尔斯所提出的成人学习者行为。
采用定性描述性研究设计,从南非一所高等教育机构的护理学院中参与高保真模拟的18名研究生护理学生那里收集数据。运用名义小组技术收集学生关于改善其模拟学习经历的想法。对原始名义小组数据进行了二次定性分析。
数据既证实了也反驳了成人学习者行为。尽管研究结果表明存在自我导向和独立的学习者行为,但也揭示了明显依赖教育工作者的行为。
成熟的学生有既定的思维和行为方式,这可能会阻碍学习。教育工作者必须支持成人学习者发展有效的学习技巧,以便通过培养独立性和自我导向来最大限度地发挥他们的经验和知识的益处。