Singleton Rivers, Singleton David R
Departments of Biological Science and English, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, 19716, USA.
Department of Biological Sciences, York College of Pennsylvania, York, PA, 17403, USA.
J Hist Biol. 2017 Feb;50(1):169-218. doi: 10.1007/s10739-016-9438-7.
The Dutch microbiologist/biochemist Albert Jan Kluyver (1888-1956) was an early proponent of the idea of biochemical unity, and how that concept might be demonstrated through the careful study of microbial life. The fundamental relatedness of living systems is an obvious correlate of the theory of evolution, and modern attempts to construct phylogenetic schemes support this relatedness through comparison of genomes. The approach of Kluyver and his scientific descendants predated the tools of modern molecular biology by decades. Kluyver himself is poorly recognized today, yet his influence at the time was profound. Through lens of today however, it has been argued that the focus by Kluyver and others to create taxonomic and phylogenetic schemes using morphology and biochemistry distorted and hindered progress of the discipline of microbiology, because of a perception that the older approaches focused too much on a reductionist worldview. This essay argues that in contrast the careful characterization of fundamental microbial metabolism and physiology by Kluyver made many of the advances of the latter part of the twentieth century possible, by offering a framework which in many respects anticipated our current view of phylogeny, and by directly and indirectly training a generation of scientists who became leaders in the explosive growth of biotechnology.
荷兰微生物学家/生物化学家阿尔伯特·扬·克吕弗(1888 - 1956)是生物化学统一性概念的早期支持者,以及如何通过对微生物生命的仔细研究来证明这一概念。生命系统的基本关联性显然是进化理论的一个相关内容,而现代构建系统发育图谱的尝试通过基因组比较来支持这种关联性。克吕弗及其科学后继者们所采用的方法比现代分子生物学工具早了几十年。如今克吕弗本人鲜为人知,但他当时的影响力却极为深远。然而,从当今的视角来看,有人认为克吕弗等人利用形态学和生物化学来创建分类学和系统发育图谱的做法扭曲并阻碍了微生物学学科的发展,原因是人们认为这些旧方法过于侧重于还原论的世界观。本文认为,与之相反,克吕弗对微生物基本代谢和生理学的细致描述使得20世纪后半叶的许多进展成为可能,他提供了一个在许多方面预见了我们当前系统发育观点的框架,并且直接或间接地培养了一代科学家,这些科学家成为了生物技术蓬勃发展中的领军人物。