Tan Ngiap Chuan, Mitesh Shah, Koh Yi Ling Eileen, Ang Seng Bin, Chan Hian Hui Vincent, How Choon How, Tay Ee Guan, Hwang Siew Wai
Department of Research, SingHealth Polyclinics, Singapore.
Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore.
Singapore Med J. 2017 Jan;58(1):35-40. doi: 10.11622/smedj.2016043. Epub 2016 Feb 19.
It is uncommon for medical students to deliver public health talks as part of their medical education curriculum. This study evaluated the effectiveness of a novel training programme that required medical students to deliver public health talks during their family medicine (FM) clerkship in a Singapore primary care institution.
The FM faculty staff guided teams of third-year medical students to select appropriate topics for health talks that were to be conducted at designated polyclinics. The talks were video-recorded and appraised for clarity, content and delivery. The appraisal was done by the student's peers and assigned faculty staff. The audience was surveyed to determine their satisfaction level and understanding of the talks. The students also self-rated the effectiveness of this new teaching activity.
A total of 120 medical students completed a questionnaire to rate the effectiveness of the new teaching activity. 85.8% of the students felt confident about the delivery of their talks, 95.8% reported having learnt how to deliver talks and 92.5% perceived this new training modality as useful in their medical education. Based on the results of the audience survey, the speakers were perceived as knowledgeable (53.1%), confident (51.3%) and professional (39.0%). Assessment of 15 video-recorded talks showed satisfactory delivery of the talks by the students.
The majority of the students reported a favourable overall learning experience under this new training programme. This finding is supported by the positive feedback garnered from the audience, peers of the medical students and the faculty staff.
医学生在医学教育课程中进行公共卫生讲座并不常见。本研究评估了一项新颖培训计划的效果,该计划要求医学生在新加坡一家基层医疗机构的家庭医学实习期间进行公共卫生讲座。
家庭医学教职员工指导三年级医学生团队为将在指定综合诊所进行的健康讲座选择合适的主题。讲座进行了录像,并从清晰度、内容和表达方面进行评估。评估由学生的同龄人及指定的教职员工进行。对听众进行调查以确定他们对讲座的满意度和理解程度。学生们也对这项新教学活动的效果进行了自我评估。
共有120名医学生完成了一份问卷,以评价这项新教学活动的效果。85.8%的学生对自己的讲座表达感到自信,95.8%的学生报告学会了如何进行讲座,92.5%的学生认为这种新的培训方式对他们的医学教育有用。根据听众调查结果,演讲者被认为知识渊博(53.1%)、自信(51.3%)和专业(39.0%)。对15场录像讲座的评估显示学生们的讲座表达令人满意。
大多数学生报告在这项新培训计划下有良好的总体学习体验。这一发现得到了来自听众、医学生的同龄人以及教职员工的积极反馈的支持。