Zaina Fabio, Donzelli Sabrina, Lusini Monia, Fusco Claudia, Minnella Salvatore, Negrini Stefano
ISICO, Italian Scientific Spine Institute, Via Bellarmino 13/1, 20141, Milan, Italy.
Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, Department of Clinical and Experimental Sciences, University of Brescia, Brescia, Italy.
Eur Spine J. 2016 Sep;25(9):2938-44. doi: 10.1007/s00586-016-4452-1. Epub 2016 Feb 26.
Tennis is widely practiced by adolescents in many countries. Many spinal deformity experts consider this activity, together with other asymmetrical sports, as risk factors for scoliosis development even though scientific data are missing. The aim of the present study was to verify the prevalence of spinal deformities and LBP in adolescent competitive tennis players compared to healthy controls.
We designed a cross-sectional study. A convenience sample of 102 adolescent tennis players (52 girls) was compared to 203 scholars (102 girls) of the same age (12 years). We used a questionnaire to collect data on LBP and we measured the ATR to screen for spinal deformities and the plumb line distances for kyphosis (C7 and C7 + L3) and lordosis (L3).
We found similar spinal deformities in both groups: ATR female: 3.2° ± 1° (tennis) versus 2.8° ± 1° (school), NS; ATR males: 2.8° ± 1° (tennis) versus 2.6° ± 1° (school), p < 0.05. No differences were found for kyphosis and lordosis. Low back pain prevalence was similar for both groups, but a significant difference was found for limitation of usual activity, which was higher for tennis players than controls.
The correlation between tennis, an asymmetric sport, and spinal deformities that has been postulated by many experts was not confirmed by our data. There was no correlation between tennis and LBP, even if there were some differences among groups for limitations of the daily activities. Adolescent competitive tennis showed to be a safe sport without an increased risk of spinal deformities and LBP.
网球运动在许多国家的青少年中广泛开展。许多脊柱畸形专家认为,这项运动以及其他不对称运动是脊柱侧弯发展的风险因素,尽管缺乏科学数据。本研究的目的是验证青少年竞技网球运动员与健康对照组相比脊柱畸形和腰痛的患病率。
我们设计了一项横断面研究。将102名青少年网球运动员(52名女孩)的便利样本与203名同龄(12岁)的学生(102名女孩)进行比较。我们使用问卷收集腰痛数据,并测量ATR以筛查脊柱畸形,以及测量后凸(C7和C7 + L3)和前凸(L3)的铅垂线距离。
我们在两组中发现了相似的脊柱畸形:女性ATR:3.2°±1°(网球组)对2.8°±1°(学生组),无统计学差异;男性ATR:2.8°±1°(网球组)对2.6°±1°(学生组),p<0.05。在后凸和前凸方面未发现差异。两组的腰痛患病率相似,但在日常活动受限方面发现了显著差异,网球运动员的受限程度高于对照组。
我们的数据未证实许多专家所假定的不对称运动网球与脊柱畸形之间的相关性。网球与腰痛之间没有相关性,即使在日常活动受限方面各组之间存在一些差异。青少年竞技网球被证明是一项安全的运动,不会增加脊柱畸形和腰痛的风险。