Byars-Winston Angela M, Branchaw Janet, Pfund Christine, Leverett Patrice, Newton Joseph
Department of Medicine and Center for Women's Health Research University of Wisconsin, 700 Regent Street Suite 301, Madison, WI 53715, phone (608) 263-1731,
WISCIENCE, Wisconsin Institute for Science Education and Community Engagement, University of Wisconsin-Madison 445 Henry Mall, Room 109A Madison, WI 53706, phone: 608-262-1182,
Int J Sci Educ. 2015;37(15):2533-2554. doi: 10.1080/09500693.2015.1085133. Epub 2015 Sep 23.
Few studies have empirically investigated the specific factors in mentoring relationships between undergraduate researchers (mentees) and their mentors in the biological and life sciences that account for mentees' positive academic and career outcomes. Using archival evaluation data from more than 400 mentees gathered over a multi-year period (2005-11) from several undergraduate biology research programs at a large, Midwestern research university, we validated existing evaluation measures of the mentored research experience and the mentor-mentee relationship. We used a subset of data from mentees (77% underrepresented racial/ethnic minorities) to test a hypothesized social cognitive career theory model of associations between mentees' academic outcomes and perceptions of their research mentoring relationships. Results from path analysis indicate that perceived mentor effectiveness indirectly predicted post-baccalaureate outcomes via research self-efficacy beliefs. Findings are discussed with implications for developing new and refining existing tools to measure this impact, programmatic interventions to increase the success of culturally diverse research mentees and future directions for research.
很少有研究实证调查过生物和生命科学领域本科研究者(学员)与其导师之间的指导关系中,导致学员取得积极学术和职业成果的具体因素。我们利用一所位于中西部的大型研究型大学多个本科生物学研究项目在多年时间(2005 - 2011年)里收集的400多名学员的档案评估数据,验证了现有的对指导研究经历和导师 - 学员关系的评估方法。我们使用了学员数据的一个子集(77%为代表性不足的少数族裔)来测试一个关于学员学术成果与其对研究指导关系认知之间关联的社会认知职业理论假设模型。路径分析结果表明,感知到的导师效能通过研究自我效能信念间接预测了本科后的成果。本文讨论了这些发现对开发新的和完善现有工具以衡量这种影响、开展项目干预以提高文化背景多样的研究学员成功率以及未来研究方向的意义。