Department of Public Health and Infectious Diseases, Sapienza University, Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, 00185 Rome, Italy.
J Dent. 2016 Jun;49:1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent.2016.04.003. Epub 2016 Apr 19.
Tuberculosis transmission among healthcare workers (HCWs) and patients is due to the level of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MT) circulation in the community and in the healthcare settings where HCWs are active. In contrast, most papers about dentistry report that dental HCWs (DHCWs) and patients are at relatively high risk, mainly based on tuberculosis case series that occurred in the 80's-90's. This meta-narrative review was designed to evaluate the tuberculosis risk in dentistry accounting for the historical-geographical contexts.
All available studies reporting data on MT infection (active/latent tuberculosis, tuberculin skin test) among patients and DHCWs.
PubMed, Scopus, GOOGLE Scholar.
MT/tuberculosis and dentistry/dentist/dental/dent*.
238 of the 351 titles were excluded because did not concern dental healthcare providing, 94 papers were excluded because they did not provide original data. Thirteen studies on occupational risk, nine on transmission to patients remained. Some, often non-confirmed, cases of MT infection among patients were reported in specific historical-geographical contexts where MT was endemic. The risk of active pulmonary tuberculosis transmission from infected DHCWs to patients is minimal today, provided that the basic infection control guidelines are applied. The development of active tuberculosis among DHCWs is occasional and is associable to MT circulation rather than dental healthcare providing.
Tuberculosis transmission in dental healthcare settings was due to the lack of basic infection control measures, while the risk is acceptable (i.e., similar to the general population) nowadays. Therefore, tuberculosis transmission can be safely prevented wearing gloves and surgical mask and providing regular air changes in the operative and non-operative dental healthcare settings. Precautionary Principle-based measures are implementable when patients with active pulmonary tuberculosis are routinely treated.
医护人员(HCWs)和患者之间的结核病传播是由于社区和 HCWs 活跃的医疗环境中结核分枝杆菌(MT)的循环水平。相比之下,大多数关于牙科的论文报告说,牙科 HCWs(DHCWs)和患者处于相对较高的风险中,主要基于 80 年代-90 年代发生的结核病病例系列。本元叙事综述旨在评估考虑历史地理背景下牙科中的结核病风险。
所有报告患者和 DHCWs 中 MT 感染(活动性/潜伏性结核病、结核菌素皮肤试验)数据的可用研究。
PubMed、Scopus、GOOGLE Scholar。
MT/结核病和牙科/牙医/牙科/牙科*。
351 个标题中有 238 个因不涉及牙科医疗保健而被排除,94 个因未提供原始数据而被排除。有 13 项关于职业风险的研究,9 项关于向患者传播的研究。在 MT 流行的特定历史地理背景下,报告了一些患者中 MT 感染的非确诊病例。如今,只要应用基本的感染控制指南,从受感染的 DHCWs 向患者传播活动性肺结核的风险就极小。DHCWs 中活动性肺结核的发展是偶然的,与 MT 的传播相关,而不是与牙科医疗保健相关。
在牙科医疗保健环境中,结核病的传播是由于缺乏基本的感染控制措施,而如今风险是可以接受的(即与一般人群相似)。因此,在手术和非手术牙科医疗保健环境中,通过戴手套和外科口罩以及定期更换空气,可以安全地预防结核病传播。当常规治疗活动性肺结核患者时,可以实施基于预防原则的措施。