Etoom Mohammad, Hawamdeh Mohannad, Hawamdeh Ziad, Alwardat Mohammad, Giordani Laura, Bacciu Serenella, Scarpini Claudia, Foti Calogero
aAdvance Sciences and Technologies in Medical Rehabilitation and Sport bPhysical Activity and Health Promotion and cPhysical and Rehabilitation Medicine, Tor Vergata University, Rome, Italy dPhysical and Occupational Therapy Department, The Hashmite University, Zarqa ePhysical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan.
Int J Rehabil Res. 2016 Sep;39(3):197-210. doi: 10.1097/MRR.0000000000000169.
Constraint-induced movement therapy (CIMT) is a neurorehabilitation technique designed to improve upper extremity motor functions after stroke. This review aimed to investigate evidence of the effect of CIMT on upper extremity in stroke patients and to identify optimal methods to apply CIMT. Four databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINHAL, and PEDro) and reference lists of relevant articles and reviews were searched. Randomized clinical trials that studied the effect of CIMT on upper extremity outcomes in stroke patients compared with other rehabilitative techniques, usual care, or no intervention were included. Methodological quality was assessed using the PEDro score. The following data were extracted for each trial: patients' characteristics, sample size, eligibility criteria, protocols of CIMT and control groups, outcome measurements, and the PEDro score. A total of 38 trials were identified according to the inclusion criteria. The trials included were heterogeneous in CIMT protocols, time since stroke, and duration and frequency of treatment. The pooled meta-analysis of 36 trials found a heterogeneous significant effect of CIMT on upper extremity. There was no significant effect of CIMT at different durations of follow-up. The majority of included articles did not fulfill powered sample size and quality criteria. The effect of CIMT changed in terms of sample size and quality features of the articles included. These meta-analysis findings indicate that evidence for the superiority of CIMT in comparison with other rehabilitative interventions is weak. Information on the optimal dose of CIMT and optimal time to start CIMT is still limited.
强制性运动疗法(CIMT)是一种神经康复技术,旨在改善中风后上肢的运动功能。本综述旨在调查CIMT对中风患者上肢影响的证据,并确定应用CIMT的最佳方法。检索了四个数据库(MEDLINE、EMBASE、CINHAL和PEDro)以及相关文章和综述的参考文献列表。纳入了与其他康复技术、常规护理或无干预措施相比,研究CIMT对中风患者上肢结局影响的随机临床试验。使用PEDro评分评估方法学质量。为每个试验提取了以下数据:患者特征、样本量、纳入标准、CIMT和对照组方案、结局测量以及PEDro评分。根据纳入标准共确定了38项试验。纳入的试验在CIMT方案、中风后的时间、治疗持续时间和频率方面存在异质性。对36项试验进行的汇总荟萃分析发现,CIMT对上肢有显著的异质性影响。在不同随访时间,CIMT没有显著影响。大多数纳入文章未达到有效样本量和质量标准。CIMT的效果根据纳入文章的样本量和质量特征而变化。这些荟萃分析结果表明,与其他康复干预措施相比,CIMT优越性的证据不足。关于CIMT的最佳剂量和开始CIMT的最佳时间的信息仍然有限。