Chan Yu-Chen
Institute of Learning Sciences, National Tsing Hua University Hsinchu, Taiwan.
Front Psychol. 2016 Apr 26;7:536. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00536. eCollection 2016.
Humor operates through a variety of techniques, which first generate surprise and then amusement and laughter once the unexpected incongruity is resolved. As different types of jokes use different techniques, the corresponding humor processes also differ. The present study builds on the framework of the 'tri-component theory of humor,' which details the mechanisms involved in cognition (comprehension), affect (appreciation), and laughter (expression). This study seeks to identify differences among joke types and between sexes/genders in the neural mechanisms underlying humor processing. Three types of verbal jokes, bridging-inference jokes (BJs), exaggeration jokes (EJs), and ambiguity jokes (AJs), were used as stimuli. The findings revealed differences in brain activity for an interaction between sex/gender and joke type. For BJs, women displayed greater activation in the temporoparietal-mesocortical-motor network than men, demonstrating the importance of the temporoparietal junction (TPJ) presumably for 'theory of mind' processing, the orbitofrontal cortex for motivational functions and reward coding, and the supplementary motor area for laughter. Women also showed greater activation than men in the frontal-mesolimbic network associated with EJs, including the anterior (frontopolar) prefrontal cortex (aPFC, BA 10) for executive control processes, and the amygdala and midbrain for reward anticipation and salience processes. Conversely, AJs elicited greater activation in men than women in the frontal-paralimbic network, including the dorsal prefrontal cortex (dPFC) and parahippocampal gyrus. All joke types elicited greater activation in the aPFC of women than of men, whereas men showed greater activation than women in the dPFC. To confirm the findings related to sex/gender differences, random group analysis and within group variance analysis were also performed. These findings help further establish the mechanisms underlying the processing of different joke types for the sexes/genders and provide a neural foundation for a theory of sex/gender differences in humor.
幽默通过多种技巧发挥作用,这些技巧首先制造惊喜,一旦意外的不协调得到解决,就会引发娱乐和笑声。由于不同类型的笑话使用不同的技巧,相应的幽默过程也有所不同。本研究建立在“幽默三成分理论”的框架之上,该理论详细阐述了认知(理解)、情感(欣赏)和笑声(表达)所涉及的机制。本研究旨在确定笑话类型之间以及性别在幽默处理背后的神经机制上的差异。三种类型的言语笑话,即搭桥推理笑话(BJ)、夸张笑话(EJ)和歧义笑话(AJ),被用作刺激物。研究结果揭示了性别与笑话类型之间相互作用在大脑活动方面的差异。对于搭桥推理笑话,女性在颞顶叶 - 中皮质 - 运动网络中的激活程度高于男性,这表明颞顶叶交界处(TPJ)可能对于“心理理论”处理、眶额皮质对于动机功能和奖励编码以及辅助运动区对于笑声具有重要性。与夸张笑话相关的额叶 - 边缘中脑网络中,女性的激活程度也高于男性,包括用于执行控制过程的前额叶前部(额极)前额皮质(aPFC,BA 10),以及用于奖励预期和显著性过程的杏仁核和中脑。相反,歧义笑话在男性的额叶 - 边缘旁网络中引发的激活程度高于女性,包括背侧前额皮质(dPFC)和海马旁回。所有笑话类型在女性的前额叶前部皮质中引发的激活程度均高于男性,而男性在背侧前额皮质中的激活程度高于女性。为了证实与性别差异相关的研究结果,还进行了随机组分析和组内方差分析。这些研究结果有助于进一步确立不同性别处理不同类型笑话背后的机制,并为幽默中性别差异理论提供神经学基础。