Syed Ahsan A, Almas Aysha, Naeem Quratulain, Malik Umer F, Muhammad Tariq
1 Department of Medicine, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
2 Thomas J. Long School of Pharmacy & Health Sciences, University of the Pacific, Stockton, CA, USA.
Palliat Med. 2017 Feb;31(2):147-157. doi: 10.1177/0269216316650789. Epub 2016 Jul 10.
In Asian societies including Pakistan, a complex background of illiteracy, different familial dynamics, lack of patient's autonomy, religious beliefs, and financial constraints give new dimensions to code status discussion. Barriers faced by physicians during code status discussion in these societies are largely unknown.
To determine the barriers and perceptions in discussion of code status by physicians.
Questionnaire-based cross-sectional study.
This study was conducted in the Department of Medicine of The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan. A total of 134 physicians who had discussed at least five code statuses in their lifetime were included.
A total of 77 (57.4%) physicians responded. Family-related barriers were found to be the most common barriers. They include family denial (74.0%), level of education of family (66.2%), and conflict between individual family members (66.2%). Regarding personal barriers, lack of knowledge regarding prognosis (44.1%), personal discomfort in discussing death (29.8%), and fear of legal consequences (28.5%) were the top most barriers. In hospital-related barriers, time constraint (57.1%), lack of hospital administration support (48.0%), and suboptimal nursing care after do not resuscitate (48.0%) were the most frequent. There were significant differences among opinions of trainees when compared to those of attending physicians.
Family-related barriers are the most frequent roadblocks in the end-of-life care discussions for physicians in Pakistan. Strengthening communication skills of physicians and family education are the potential strategies to improve end-of-life care. Large multi-center studies are needed to better understand the barriers of code status discussion in developing countries.
在包括巴基斯坦在内的亚洲社会,文盲、不同的家庭动态、患者缺乏自主权、宗教信仰以及经济限制等复杂背景为关于代码状态的讨论赋予了新的维度。在这些社会中,医生在进行代码状态讨论时所面临的障碍很大程度上尚不为人所知。
确定医生在讨论代码状态时的障碍和看法。
基于问卷的横断面研究。
本研究在巴基斯坦卡拉奇阿迦汗大学医院内科进行。共有134名一生中至少讨论过五次代码状态的医生纳入研究。
共有77名(57.4%)医生做出回应。发现与家庭相关的障碍是最常见的障碍。包括家庭拒绝(74.0%)、家庭成员的教育水平(66.2%)以及家庭成员之间的冲突(66.2%)。关于个人障碍,对预后缺乏了解(44.1%)、讨论死亡时个人不适(29.8%)以及对法律后果的恐惧(28.5%)是最主要的障碍。在与医院相关的障碍中,时间限制(57.1%)、缺乏医院管理支持(48.0%)以及在下达不进行心肺复苏医嘱后的护理服务欠佳(48.0%)最为常见。与主治医生相比,实习医生的意见存在显著差异。
在巴基斯坦,与家庭相关的障碍是医生在临终关怀讨论中最常见的阻碍。加强医生的沟通技巧和家庭教育是改善临终关怀的潜在策略。需要开展大型多中心研究,以更好地了解发展中国家在代码状态讨论方面的障碍。