Tomita K, Tsuchiya H
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, School of Medicine, Kanazawa University, Japan.
J Surg Oncol. 1989 Jun;41(2):71-6. doi: 10.1002/jso.2930410204.
This is a 2-7-year follow-up report by 21 institutes in Japan concerning limb-salvage surgery for osteosarcoma. Between 1980 and 1985, 248 patients with osteosarcoma were treated, and 105 patients had limb-salvage surgery. The percentage of cases treated by limb-salvage surgery increased with each year. The cumulative survival rate was 71% at 5 years in the limb-salvage group, and in the amputation group it was 46%; this indicates that cases for limb-salvage patients, tumor resection was classified this procedure. In limb-salvage patients, tumor resection was classified according to the surgical margin as intralesional excision, marginal excision, wide-with-marginal resection, wide resection, and radical resection. Wide resection was performed in most cases as the method of choice. Local recurrence was seen in 13 cases (12%). The overall functional evaluations by Enneking's system showed that the number of results rated excellent or good was relatively high in the early follow-up period, but this decreased later on, and cases rated fair or poor increased as the years passed. This was mainly due to postsurgical complications (44 cases). We identify a few problems in the functional evaluation system used now and suggest a reform of the system, so that physical and mental factors would be evaluated separately.
这是日本21家机构关于骨肉瘤保肢手术的2至7年随访报告。1980年至1985年期间,共治疗了248例骨肉瘤患者,其中105例行保肢手术。保肢手术治疗的病例百分比逐年增加。保肢组5年累积生存率为71%,截肢组为46%;这表明对于保肢患者,肿瘤切除按此程序分类。在保肢患者中,肿瘤切除根据手术切缘分为病损内切除、边缘切除、广泛边缘切除、广泛切除和根治性切除。大多数病例采用广泛切除作为首选方法。13例(12%)出现局部复发。根据恩内金系统进行的总体功能评估显示,在随访早期,评为优秀或良好的结果数量相对较高,但后来有所下降,随着时间推移,评为一般或差的病例增加。这主要是由于术后并发症(44例)。我们发现了目前使用的功能评估系统中的一些问题,并建议对该系统进行改革,以便分别评估身体和心理因素。