Mastnardo Diane, Lewis Janice M, Hall Kristi, Sullivan Catherine M, Cain Katrice, Theurer Jacqueline, Huml Anne, Sehgal Ashwini R
Case Western Reserve University and MetroHealth Medical Center, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Int J Ther Massage Bodywork. 2016 Jun 3;9(2):3-8. doi: 10.3822/ijtmb.v9i2.305. eCollection 2016 Jun.
Patients on hemodialysis often experience muscle cramps that result in discomfort, shortened treatment times, and inadequate dialysis dose. Cramps have been associated with adversely affecting sleep and health-related quality of life, depression and anxiety. There is limited evidence available about massage in dialysis; however, massage in cancer patients has demonstrated decreases in pain, inflammation, and feelings of anxiety. These correlations indicate massage may be an effective treatment modality for hemodialysis-related lower extremity cramping.
To determine the effectiveness of intradialytic massage on the frequency of cramping among hemodialysis patients prone to lower extremity cramping.
26 maintenance hemodialysis patients with frequent lower extremity cramps.
three outpatient hemodialysis centers in Northeast Ohio.
randomized controlled trial.
The intervention group received a 20-minute massage of the lower extremities during each treatment (three times per week) for two weeks. The control group received usual care by dialysis center staff.
change in frequency of lower leg cramping.
Patient reported cramping at home decreased by 1.3 episodes per week in the intervention group compared to 0.2 episodes per week in the control group (p=.005). Patient reported cramping during dialysis decreased by 0.8 episodes in the intervention group compared to 0.4 episodes in the control group (p=0.44).
Intradialytic massage appears to be an effective way to address muscle cramping. Larger studies with longer duration should be conducted to further examine this approach.
接受血液透析的患者经常会出现肌肉痉挛,这会导致不适、缩短治疗时间以及透析剂量不足。痉挛与睡眠、健康相关生活质量、抑郁和焦虑受到负面影响有关。关于透析中按摩的证据有限;然而,癌症患者的按摩已显示出疼痛、炎症和焦虑感有所减轻。这些相关性表明按摩可能是治疗血液透析相关下肢痉挛的有效方法。
确定透析期间按摩对易发生下肢痉挛的血液透析患者痉挛频率的有效性。
26名经常出现下肢痉挛的维持性血液透析患者。
俄亥俄州东北部的三个门诊血液透析中心。
随机对照试验。
干预组在每次治疗期间(每周三次)接受20分钟的下肢按摩,持续两周。对照组接受透析中心工作人员的常规护理。
小腿痉挛频率的变化。
干预组患者报告的在家中痉挛次数每周减少1.3次,而对照组为每周减少0.2次(p = 0.005)。干预组患者报告的透析期间痉挛次数减少0.8次,而对照组减少0.4次(p = 0.44)。
透析期间按摩似乎是解决肌肉痉挛的有效方法。应进行更大规模、持续时间更长的研究以进一步检验这种方法。