Varghese Akshay, Lacson Eduardo, Sontrop Jessica M, Acedillo Rey R, Al-Jaishi Ahmed A, Anderson Sierra, Bagga Amit, Bain Katie L, Bennett Laura L, Bohm Clara, Brown Pierre A, Chan Christopher T, Cote Brenden, Dev Varun, Field Bonnie, Harris Claire, Kalatharan Shasikara, Kiaii Mercedeh, Molnar Amber O, Oliver Matthew J, Parmar Malvinder S, Schorr Melissa, Shah Nikhil, Silver Samuel A, Smith D Michael, Sood Manish M, St Louis Irina, Tennankore Karthik K, Thompson Stephanie, Tonelli Marcello, Vorster Hans, Waldvogel Blair, Zacharias James, Garg Amit X
Division of Nephrology, Department of Medicine, London Health Sciences Centre, London, ON, Canada.
Division of Nephrology, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Can J Kidney Health Dis. 2020 Oct 22;7:2054358120964078. doi: 10.1177/2054358120964078. eCollection 2020.
Strategies to mitigate muscle cramps are a top research priority for patients receiving hemodialysis. As hypomagnesemia is a possible risk factor for cramping, we reviewed the literature to better understand the physiology of cramping as well as the epidemiology of hypomagnesemia and muscle cramps. We also sought to review the evidence from interventional studies on the effect of oral and dialysate magnesium-based therapies on muscle cramps.
Peer-reviewed articles.
We searched for relevant articles in major bibliographic databases including MEDLINE and EMBASE. The methodological quality of interventional studies was assessed using a modified version of the Downs and Blacks criteria checklist.
The etiology of muscle cramps in patients receiving hemodialysis is poorly understood and there are no clear evidence-based prevention or treatment strategies. Several factors may play a role including a low concentration of serum magnesium. The prevalence of hypomagnesemia (concentration of <0.7 mmol/L) in patients receiving hemodialysis ranges from 10% to 20%. Causes of hypomagnesemia include a low dietary intake of magnesium, use of medications that inhibit magnesium absorption (eg, proton pump inhibitors), increased magnesium excretion (eg, high-dose loop diuretics), and a low concentration of dialysate magnesium. Dialysate magnesium concentrations of ≤0.5 mmol/L may be associated with a decrease in serum magnesium concentration over time. Preliminary evidence from observational and interventional studies suggests a higher dialysate magnesium concentration will raise serum magnesium concentrations and may reduce the frequency and severity of muscle cramps. However, the quality of evidence supporting this benefit is limited, and larger, multicenter clinical trials are needed to further determine if magnesium-based therapy can reduce muscle cramps in patients receiving hemodialysis. In studies conducted to date, increasing the concentration of dialysate magnesium appears to be well-tolerated and is associated with a low risk of symptomatic hypermagnesemia.
Few interventional studies have examined the effect of magnesium-based therapy on muscle cramps in patients receiving hemodialysis and most were nonrandomized, pre-post study designs.
减轻肌肉痉挛的策略是接受血液透析患者的首要研究重点。由于低镁血症是痉挛的一个可能危险因素,我们回顾了文献,以更好地理解痉挛的生理学以及低镁血症和肌肉痉挛的流行病学。我们还试图回顾关于口服和透析液中基于镁的疗法对肌肉痉挛影响的干预性研究证据。
同行评审文章。
我们在包括MEDLINE和EMBASE在内的主要文献数据库中搜索相关文章。使用唐斯和布莱克标准清单的修改版评估干预性研究的方法学质量。
血液透析患者肌肉痉挛的病因尚不清楚,且没有明确的循证预防或治疗策略。几个因素可能起作用,包括血清镁浓度低。接受血液透析患者中低镁血症(浓度<0.7 mmol/L)的患病率为10%至20%。低镁血症的原因包括饮食中镁摄入量低、使用抑制镁吸收的药物(如质子泵抑制剂)、镁排泄增加(如大剂量袢利尿剂)以及透析液镁浓度低。透析液镁浓度≤0.5 mmol/L可能与血清镁浓度随时间下降有关。观察性和干预性研究的初步证据表明,较高的透析液镁浓度会提高血清镁浓度,并可能降低肌肉痉挛的频率和严重程度。然而,支持这一益处的证据质量有限,需要进行更大规模的多中心临床试验,以进一步确定基于镁的疗法是否能减少接受血液透析患者的肌肉痉挛。在迄今为止进行的研究中,提高透析液镁浓度似乎耐受性良好,且与有症状高镁血症的低风险相关。
很少有干预性研究考察基于镁的疗法对接受血液透析患者肌肉痉挛的影响,且大多数为非随机的前后对照研究设计。