Ibarz-Pavón A B, Papaventsis D, Kalkouni R, Metaxas G, Spala G, Georgakopoulou T, Gerakis T, Pefanis A, Vogiatzakis E
European Programme for Public Health Microbiology Training, European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, Stockholm, Sweden; National School of Public Health, Athens, Greece; Hellenic Centre for Disease Control and Prevention, Athens, Greece.
Microbiology Laboratory & National Reference Laboratory for Mycobacteria, Athens, Greece.
Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2016 Jul;20(7):920-5. doi: 10.5588/ijtld.15.0907.
Sotiria Chest Diseases Hospital (SCDH), a referral hospital in Athens, Greece, 2012.
To assess the completeness of the mandatory notification system for tuberculosis (TB) at the SCDH, and compare the observed and estimated annual incidence rates.
Record linkage and the capture-recapture method were applied. Data sources were the registers from the national mandatory notification register (Hellenic Centre for Disease Control and Prevention [HCDCP]), the National Reference Laboratory for Mycobacteria (NRLM) and SCDH records. The log-linear model with the lowest Akaike information criterion was selected as the most valid statistical model.
The observed and estimated TB under-reporting rates at the national level were respectively 55% (95%CI 49-60) and 75% (95%CI 71-78). The observed completeness of the HCDCP, NRLM and SCDH registers were respectively 45% (95%CI 40-51), 66% (95%CI 61-71) and 36.5% (95%CI 31-42). The estimated TB incidence rate was 15 cases per 100 000 (range 13-19/100 000), compared to the 4.9/100 000 rate officially notified.
Adult TB incidence has been largely underestimated, and the TB burden is likely to be much higher than officially notified in our setting. A thorough review of the notification system should be carried out. The implementation of a network-based notification system and retraining of all relevant personnel is advised.
2012年,希腊雅典的索蒂里亚胸科疾病医院(SCDH),一家转诊医院。
评估SCDH结核病(TB)强制报告系统的完整性,并比较观察到的和估计的年发病率。
采用记录链接和捕获再捕获方法。数据来源是国家强制报告登记册(希腊疾病控制和预防中心[HCDCP])、国家分枝杆菌参考实验室(NRLM)的登记册以及SCDH的记录。选择具有最低赤池信息准则的对数线性模型作为最有效的统计模型。
在国家层面,观察到的和估计的结核病漏报率分别为55%(95%可信区间49 - 60)和75%(95%可信区间71 - 78)。HCDCP、NRLM和SCDH登记册观察到的完整性分别为45%(95%可信区间40 - 51)、66%(95%可信区间61 - 71)和36.5%(95%可信区间31 - 42)。估计的结核病发病率为每10万人15例(范围13 - 19/10万),而官方通报的发病率为4.9/10万。
成人结核病发病率被严重低估,在我们的环境中,结核病负担可能比官方通报的要高得多。应对报告系统进行全面审查。建议实施基于网络的报告系统并对所有相关人员进行再培训。