Edelstein Arnon
1 Kaye Academic College, Beersheba, Israel.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2018 Feb;62(2):383-403. doi: 10.1177/0306624X16652453. Epub 2016 Jun 20.
Ethiopian immigrant women in Israel are overrepresented as victims of femicide; they are killed at more than 16 times the rate of the general population. This article suggests integrating current theoretical and empirical models to explain Ethiopian femicide, and stresses that considering psychological or sociocultural explanations as risk factors alone is not enough to understand this phenomenon. We distinguish between risk factors and triggers for femicide against Ethiopian women. While sociocultural and even psychological changes are risk factors for femicide, one, two, or three main triggers may activate such potential risk factors, such as the woman's willingness (WW) to leave the intimate relationship, sexual jealousy (SJ), and formal complaints against the abusive partner. The first two triggers are jealousy oriented. To analyze this phenomenon in Israel, we examined all court decisions on intimate partner homicide (IPH) from 1990 to 2010. After reading former studies on IPH and identifying important variables that could explain the phenomenon, we first catalogued the data in every decision and verdict according to main independent variables mentioned in the literature. The study population consists of first-generation immigrants, N = 194: native Israelis (47%), new immigrants from the former Soviet Union (FSU; 31%), and Ethiopians (16%). Our analysis of court decisions reveals that triggers containing jealousy components are responsible for 83% of femicide cases committed by Ethiopian men, in comparison with native Israelis (77%) and immigrant Russian men (66%) who murdered their intimate partners. In addition, there is a significant correlation among motive (jealousy), method of killing (stabbing), and "overkilling" (excessive force).
在以色列,埃塞俄比亚移民女性作为杀害妇女行为受害者的比例过高;她们被杀害的比率是普通人群的16倍多。本文建议整合当前的理论和实证模型来解释针对埃塞俄比亚女性的杀害妇女行为,并强调仅将心理或社会文化解释视为风险因素不足以理解这一现象。我们区分了针对埃塞俄比亚女性的杀害妇女行为的风险因素和触发因素。虽然社会文化甚至心理变化是杀害妇女行为的风险因素,但一个、两个或三个主要触发因素可能会激活这些潜在风险因素,例如女性离开亲密关系的意愿(WW)、性嫉妒(SJ)以及对虐待伴侣的正式投诉。前两个触发因素以嫉妒为导向。为了分析以色列的这一现象,我们研究了1990年至2010年期间所有关于亲密伴侣杀人案(IPH)的法院判决。在阅读了以前关于亲密伴侣杀人案的研究并确定了可以解释这一现象的重要变量后,我们首先根据文献中提到的主要自变量对每个判决和裁决中的数据进行了分类。研究对象包括第一代移民,N = 194:以色列本地人(47%)、前苏联(FSU)的新移民(31%)和埃塞俄比亚人(16%)。我们对法院判决的分析表明,包含嫉妒成分的触发因素导致埃塞俄比亚男性犯下的杀害妇女案件占83%,相比之下,杀害亲密伴侣的以色列本地男性(77%)和俄罗斯移民男性(66%)。此外,动机(嫉妒)、杀人方式(刺伤)和“过度杀戮”(过度使用武力)之间存在显著相关性。