Mikhael Ehab Mudher
Baghdad University, Baghdad, Iraq.
Glob Pediatr Health. 2015 Oct 6;2:2333794X15608716. doi: 10.1177/2333794X15608716. eCollection 2015.
Breast-feeding is the best method of feeding infants. In some cases, formula milk can be a suitable alternative, so this study aimed to compare the safety and nutritional adequacy of commonly available formula milks in the Iraqi market. An observational study for the commonly available formula milks was conducted in the largest supermarkets of Baghdad, Iraq, during January-March 2015. The macronutrient and micronutrient contents as presented in the label of each type of formula milk was compared with the standard requirement of formula milk according to the European Society for Paediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition (ESPGHAN) guidelines. Dielac formula milk is the commonest formula milk in the Iraqi market, with the lowest price when compared with other formula milks. All infant formula milks (Similac, Guigoz, and S-26 Gold) except Dielac have the mandatory contents within the specified ranges, according to the ESPGHAN guidelines. Dielac lacks more than 1 of the major mandatory contents besides lacking all optional contents in its formula. Guigoz formula milk lacks the optional ingredients arachidonic acid, docosahexaenoic acid, and nucleotides. Similac milk was supplemented with a higher-than-specified level of nucleotides, and its l-carnitine contents were not declared. Only S26 Gold formula milk contained all mandatory and optional ingredients within the specified range, according to the ESPGHAN guidelines. In conclusion, no formula milk can resemble breast milk; however, S26 Gold formula milk is the most acceptable formula, and Dielac formula milk is the worst. Therefore, it is recommended that Dielac be withdrawn from the Iraqi market.
母乳喂养是喂养婴儿的最佳方式。在某些情况下,配方奶可以作为一种合适的替代选择,因此本研究旨在比较伊拉克市场上常见配方奶的安全性和营养充足性。2015年1月至3月期间,在伊拉克巴格达最大的超市对常见配方奶进行了一项观察性研究。将每种配方奶标签上列出的宏量营养素和微量营养素含量与欧洲儿科胃肠病学、肝病学和营养学会(ESPGHAN)指南中配方奶的标准要求进行比较。迪艾力克配方奶是伊拉克市场上最常见的配方奶,与其他配方奶相比价格最低。根据ESPGHAN指南除迪艾力克外,所有婴儿配方奶(雅培喜康宝、雀巢能恩和惠氏金装爱儿乐)的强制成分都在规定范围内。迪艾力克除了在配方中缺少所有可选成分外,还缺少超过一种的主要强制成分。雀巢能恩配方奶缺少可选成分花生四烯酸、二十二碳六烯酸和核苷酸。雅培喜康宝奶粉添加的核苷酸水平高于规定水平,且未标明左旋肉碱含量。根据ESPGHAN指南,只有惠氏金装爱儿乐配方奶在规定范围内包含所有强制和可选成分。总之,没有一种配方奶能与母乳相似;然而,惠氏金装爱儿乐配方奶是最可接受的配方奶,而迪艾力克配方奶是最差的。因此,建议将迪艾力克从伊拉克市场撤出。