Allred Clint, Berlacher Kathryn, Aggarwal Saurabh, Auseon Alex J
J Grad Med Educ. 2016 Jul;8(3):341-5. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-15-00285.1.
Cardiology fellowship programs are at the interface of medical education and the care of patients suffering from the leading cause of mortality in the United States, yet there is an apparent lack of research guiding the effective education of fellows.
We sought to quantify the number of publications in cardiology journals that pertained to the education of cardiology trainees and the number of cardiologists participating in education research.
For the period between January and December 2012, we cataloged cardiology-specific and general medical/medical education journals and sorted them by impact factor. Tables of content were reviewed for articles with an educational focus, a cardiology focus, or both. We recorded the authors' areas of medical training, and keywords from each cardiology journal's mission statement were reviewed for emphasis on education.
Twenty-six cardiology journals, containing 6645 articles, were reviewed. Only 4 articles had education themes. Ten general medical and 15 medical education journals contained 6810 articles. Of these, only 7 focused on medical education in cardiology, and none focused on cardiology fellowship training. Among the 4887 authors of publications in medical education journals, 25 were cardiologists (less than 1%), and among the 1036 total words in the mission statements of all cardiology journals, the term "education" appeared once.
Published educational research is lacking in cardiology training, and few cardiologists appear to be active members of the education scholarship community. Cardiology organizations and academic journals should support efforts to identify target areas of study and publish scholarship in educational innovation.
心脏病学 fellowship 项目处于医学教育与美国主要死因患者护理的交叉点,但明显缺乏指导 fellows 有效教育的研究。
我们试图量化心脏病学期刊中与心脏病学实习生教育相关的出版物数量以及参与教育研究的心脏病专家数量。
对于 2012 年 1 月至 12 月期间,我们编目了心脏病学特定期刊和一般医学/医学教育期刊,并按影响因子进行排序。审查了各期刊的目录,以查找具有教育重点、心脏病学重点或两者兼具的文章。我们记录了作者的医学培训领域,并审查了各心脏病学期刊使命声明中的关键词,以查看对教育的强调情况。
审查了 26 种心脏病学期刊,共包含 6645 篇文章。只有 4 篇文章有教育主题。10 种一般医学期刊和 15 种医学教育期刊包含 6810 篇文章。其中,只有 7 篇关注心脏病学中的医学教育,没有一篇关注心脏病学 fellowship 培训。在医学教育期刊出版物的 4887 位作者中,有 25 位是心脏病专家(不到 1%),在所有心脏病学期刊使命声明的 1036 个总单词中,“教育”一词仅出现一次。
心脏病学培训方面缺乏已发表的教育研究,似乎很少有心脏病专家是教育学术团体的活跃成员。心脏病学组织和学术期刊应支持确定研究目标领域并发表教育创新学术成果的努力。