Wadephul Franziska, Jones Catriona, Jomeen Julie
Faculty of Health and Social Care, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, UK.
Healthcare (Basel). 2016 Jun 8;4(2):32. doi: 10.3390/healthcare4020032.
Depression, anxiety and stress in the perinatal period can have serious, long-term consequences for women, their babies and their families. Over the last two decades, an increasing number of group interventions with a psychological approach have been developed to improve the psychological well-being of pregnant women. This systematic review examines interventions targeting women with elevated symptoms of, or at risk of developing, perinatal mental health problems, with the aim of understanding the successful and unsuccessful features of these interventions. We systematically searched online databases to retrieve qualitative and quantitative studies on psychological antenatal group interventions. A total number of 19 papers describing 15 studies were identified; these included interventions based on cognitive behavioural therapy, interpersonal therapy and mindfulness. Quantitative findings suggested beneficial effects in some studies, particularly for women with high baseline symptoms. However, overall there is insufficient quantitative evidence to make a general recommendation for antenatal group interventions. Qualitative findings suggest that women and their partners experience these interventions positively in terms of psychological wellbeing and providing reassurance of their 'normality'. This review suggests that there are some benefits to attending group interventions, but further research is required to fully understand their successful and unsuccessful features.
围产期的抑郁、焦虑和压力会对女性、她们的婴儿及其家庭产生严重的长期影响。在过去二十年中,越来越多采用心理学方法的团体干预措施得以开发,以改善孕妇的心理健康。本系统评价考察了针对有围产期心理健康问题症状或有发展风险的女性的干预措施,旨在了解这些干预措施的成功与失败之处。我们系统地检索了在线数据库,以获取有关心理产前团体干预的定性和定量研究。共识别出19篇描述15项研究的论文;这些研究包括基于认知行为疗法、人际疗法和正念的干预措施。定量研究结果表明,在一些研究中干预措施有有益效果,特别是对基线症状较高的女性。然而,总体而言,没有足够的定量证据对产前团体干预措施给出一般性建议。定性研究结果表明,女性及其伴侣在心理健康方面以及在确认自身“正常”方面对这些干预措施有积极体验。本评价表明,参加团体干预措施有一些益处,但需要进一步研究以全面了解其成功与失败之处。