Magnée Tessa, de Beurs Derek P, de Bakker Dinny H, Verhaak Peter F
Netherlands Institute of Health Services Research (NIVEL), Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Netherlands Institute of Health Services Research (NIVEL), Utrecht, The Netherlands Tilburg University, Scientific Centre for Transformation in Care and Welfare (TRANZO), Tilburg, The Netherlands.
BMJ Open. 2016 Jul 18;6(7):e011579. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-011579.
To investigate care for patients with psychological or social problems provided by mental health nurses (MHNs), and by general practitioners (GPs) with and without MHNs.
An observational study with consultations recorded by GPs and MHNs.
Data were routinely recorded in 161-338 Dutch general practices between 2010 and 2014.
All patients registered at participating general practices were included: 624 477 patients in 2010 to 1 392 187 patients in 2014.
We used logistic and Poisson multilevel regression models to test whether GPs recorded more patients with at least one consultation for psychological or social problems and to analyse the number of consultations over a 5-year time period. We examined the additional effect of an MHN in a practice, and tested which patient characteristics predicted transferral from GPs to MHNs.
Increasing numbers of patients with psychological or social problems visit general practices. Increasing numbers of GPs collaborate with an MHN. GPs working in practices with an MHN record as many consultations per patient as GPs without an MHN, but they record slightly more patients with psychological or social problems (OR=1.05; 95% CI 1.02 to 1.08). MHNs most often treat adult female patients with common psychological symptoms such as depressive feelings.
MHNs do not seem to replace GP care, but mainly provide additional long consultations. Future research should study to what extent collaboration with an MHN prevents patients from needing specialised mental healthcare.
调查精神科护士(MHN)以及有无精神科护士协助的全科医生(GP)为有心理或社会问题的患者提供的护理情况。
一项观察性研究,由全科医生和精神科护士记录会诊情况。
2010年至2014年期间,在荷兰161 - 338家全科诊所常规记录数据。
纳入所有在参与研究的全科诊所登记的患者:2010年有624477名患者,2014年有1392187名患者。
我们使用逻辑回归和泊松多水平回归模型来测试全科医生是否记录了更多至少有一次心理或社会问题会诊的患者,并分析5年期间的会诊次数。我们研究了诊所中精神科护士的额外作用,并测试了哪些患者特征可预测从全科医生转诊至精神科护士。
有心理或社会问题的患者就诊全科诊所的人数不断增加。与精神科护士合作的全科医生数量也在增加。在有精神科护士的诊所工作的全科医生记录的每位患者会诊次数与没有精神科护士的全科医生相同,但他们记录的有心理或社会问题的患者略多(比值比=1.05;95%置信区间1.02至1.08)。精神科护士最常治疗有常见心理症状(如抑郁情绪)的成年女性患者。
精神科护士似乎并未取代全科医生的护理,而是主要提供额外的长时间会诊。未来的研究应探讨与精神科护士合作在多大程度上可防止患者需要专门的精神科护理。