Stanko Katie E, Cherry Katie E, Ryker Kyle S, Mughal Farra, Marks Loren D, Brown Jennifer Silva, Gendusa Patricia F, Sullivan Marisa C, Bruner John, Welsh David A, Su L Joseph, Jazwinski S Michal
Louisiana State University.
Louisiana State University Health Science Center.
Curr Psychol. 2015 Sep;34(3):564-575. doi: 10.1007/s12144-015-9366-2. Epub 2015 Aug 15.
Looking for potentially positive outcomes is one way that people cope with stressful events. In two studies, we examined perceived "silver linings" after the 2005 Hurricanes Katrina and Rita among indirectly affected adults. In Study 1, middle-aged (ages 47-64 years), older (ages 65-89 years), and oldest-old (ages 90-95 years) adults in the Louisiana Healthy Aging Study (LHAS) responded to an open-ended question on perceived silver linings in a longitudinal assessment carried out during the immediate impact (1 to 4 months after landfall) and post-disaster recovery phase (6 to 14 months post-storm). Qualitative grounded theory methods were employed to analyze these narrative data. Team-based coding yielded three core themes: (1) learning experience and better preparedness for future disasters, (2) having improved cities (Baton Rouge and New Orleans), and (3) an increase in "Good Samaritan" acts such as strangers helping one another. Responses were similar across age groups, although older adults were the least likely to report positive outcomes. Study 2 was a conceptual replication using a different sample of adults (ages 31 to 82 years) tested at least five years after the storms. A learning experience and preparedness core theme replicated Study 1's findings while improved social cohesion amongst family and friends emerged as a new core theme in Study 2. These data indicate that identifying lessons learned and potentially positive outcomes are psychological reactions that may facilitate post-disaster coping and foster resilience for indirectly affected adults in the years after disaster.
寻找潜在的积极结果是人们应对压力事件的一种方式。在两项研究中,我们调查了2005年卡特里娜飓风和丽塔飓风过后间接受到影响的成年人所感知到的“一线希望”。在研究1中,路易斯安那健康老龄化研究(LHAS)中的中年(47至64岁)、老年(65至89岁)和高龄老人(90至95岁)成年人,在即时影响期(登陆后1至4个月)和灾后恢复阶段(风暴后6至14个月)进行的纵向评估中,回答了一个关于感知到的一线希望的开放式问题。采用定性扎根理论方法分析这些叙述性数据。基于团队的编码产生了三个核心主题:(1)学习经验和对未来灾难的更好准备,(2)城市(巴吞鲁日和新奥尔良)得到改善,(3)“见义勇为”行为增加,比如陌生人互相帮助。各年龄组的回答相似,不过老年人报告积极结果的可能性最小。研究2是一项概念性重复研究,使用了不同的成年人样本(31至82岁),在风暴过后至少五年进行测试。一个学习经验和准备的核心主题重复了研究1的结果,而家庭和朋友之间增强的社会凝聚力在研究2中成为一个新的核心主题。这些数据表明,总结经验教训和潜在的积极结果是心理反应,可能有助于灾后应对,并在灾难后的几年里培养间接受到影响的成年人的复原力。