Coccaro Emil F, Fridberg Daniel J, Fanning Jennifer R, Grant Jon E, King Andrea C, Lee Royce
Clinical Neuroscience Research Unit, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neuroscience, Pritzker School of Medicine, The University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
J Psychiatr Res. 2016 Oct;81:127-32. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2016.06.011. Epub 2016 Jun 16.
A relationship between substance use and aggression has been noted for decades. While substance use appears to be associated with an increased risk of aggressive behavior, no study has yet reported on the pattern of comorbidity and temporal relationship between impulsive aggression (i.e., intermittent explosive disorder) and substance use disorders (SUD), specifically.
To specify these relationships, we examined DSM-5 diagnosis data from diagnostic interviews of 1355 adults who met one of five non-overlapping diagnostic subgroups: those with intermittent explosive disorder (IED; n = 339), those with SUD (n = 136), IED+SUD (n = 280), adults with psychiatric disorders but no SUD or IED (n = 320), and healthy
HC, n = 282).
Occurrence of lifetime SUD was elevated in IED vs. all Non-IED subjects (Odds Ratio: 3.61 [95% CI: 2.82-4.63]) and onset of IED preceded SUD in 80% of comorbid IED+SUD cases. Examination of the severity of impulsive aggression and SUD revealed that IED increased SUD severity but the presence of SUD did not increase severity of IED core features, including aggression, anger, or impulsivity.
Subjects with IED are at increased risk of developing substance use disorder, compared to those without IED. This suggests that history of recurrent, problematic, impulsive aggression is a risk factor for the later development of SUD rather than the reverse. Thus, effective treatment of impulsive aggression, before the onset of substance misuse, may prevent or delay the development of SUD in young individuals.
物质使用与攻击行为之间的关系已被关注数十年。虽然物质使用似乎与攻击性行为风险增加有关,但尚无研究专门报告冲动性攻击(即间歇性爆发障碍)与物质使用障碍(SUD)之间的共病模式和时间关系。
为明确这些关系,我们检查了1355名成年人诊断访谈中的DSM-5诊断数据,这些成年人属于五个非重叠诊断亚组之一:患有间歇性爆发障碍(IED;n = 339)的人、患有物质使用障碍(SUD;n = 136)的人、患有IED+SUD(n = 280)的人、患有精神疾病但无SUD或IED的成年人(n = 320)以及健康对照组(HC,n = 282)。
与所有非IED受试者相比,IED患者终身发生SUD的几率升高(优势比:3.61 [95%置信区间:2.82 - 4.63]),并且在80%的共病IED+SUD病例中,IED的发病先于SUD。对冲动性攻击和SUD严重程度的检查表明,IED会增加SUD的严重程度,但SUD的存在并不会增加IED核心特征(包括攻击、愤怒或冲动)的严重程度。
与没有IED的人相比,患有IED的受试者发生物质使用障碍的风险增加。这表明反复出现的、有问题的冲动性攻击史是SUD后期发展的一个风险因素,而非相反。因此,在物质滥用开始之前有效治疗冲动性攻击,可能会预防或延缓年轻人中SUD的发展。