Greenberg Rebecca A, Kim Celine, Stolte Helen, Hellmann Jonathan, Shaul Randi Zlotnik, Valani Rahim, Scolnik Dennis
Department of Bioethics, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of Emergency Medicine, Health Sciences Centre, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2016 Jul 27;16:193. doi: 10.1186/s12909-016-0711-4.
The World Health Organization calls for stronger cross-cultural emphasis in medical training. Bioethics education can build such competencies as it involves the conscious exploration and application of values and principles. The International Pediatric Emergency Medicine Elective (IPEME), a novel global health elective, brings together 12 medical students from Canada and the Middle East for a 4-week, living and studying experience. It is based at a Canadian children's hospital and, since its creation in 2004, ethics has informally been part of its curriculum. Our study sought to determine the content and format of an ideal bioethics curriculum for a culturally diverse group of medical students.
We conducted semi-structured interviews with students and focus groups with faculty to examine the cultural context and ethical issues of the elective. Three areas were explored: 1) Needs Analysis - students' current understanding of bioethics, prior bioethics education and desire for a formal ethics curriculum, 2) Teaching formats - students' and faculty's preferred teaching formats, and 3) Curriculum Content - students' and faculty's preferred subjects for a curriculum.
While only some students had received formal ethics training prior to this program, all understood that it was a necessary and desirable subject for formal training. Interactive teaching formats were the most preferred and truth-telling was considered the most important subject.
This study helps inform good practices for ethics education. Although undertaken with a specific cohort of students engaging in a health-for-peace elective, it may be applicable to many medical education settings since diversity of student bodies is increasing world-wide.
世界卫生组织呼吁在医学培训中更加强调跨文化内容。生物伦理学教育能够培养此类能力,因为它涉及对价值观和原则的有意识探索与应用。国际儿科急诊医学选修课(IPEME)是一门全新的全球健康选修课,它汇聚了来自加拿大和中东的12名医学生,开展为期4周的生活与学习体验。该课程以一家加拿大儿童医院为基地,自2004年开设以来,伦理学已非正式地成为其课程的一部分。我们的研究旨在确定针对文化背景多样的医学生群体的理想生物伦理学课程的内容和形式。
我们对学生进行了半结构化访谈,并与教师进行了焦点小组讨论,以审视该选修课的文化背景和伦理问题。探讨了三个领域:1)需求分析——学生对生物伦理学的当前理解、先前的生物伦理学教育以及对正式伦理学课程的期望;2)教学形式——学生和教师偏爱的教学形式;3)课程内容——学生和教师对课程偏爱的主题。
虽然在此项目之前只有部分学生接受过正式的伦理学培训,但所有人都明白这是正式培训中一门必要且受欢迎的学科。互动式教学形式最受青睐,讲真话被认为是最重要的主题。
本研究有助于为伦理学教育提供良好实践经验。尽管该研究是针对参与和平促进健康选修课的特定学生群体开展的,但由于全球范围内学生群体的多样性在增加,它可能适用于许多医学教育环境。