Baczynska Alicja M, Lim Stephen Er, Sayer Avan A, Roberts Helen C
Academic Geriatric Medicine, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
NIHR Southampton Biomedical Research Centre, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
J Clin Nurs. 2016 Nov;25(21-22):3102-3112. doi: 10.1111/jocn.13317. Epub 2016 Aug 1.
To review current evidence for the use of volunteers to mobilise older acute medical in-patients.
Immobility in hospital is associated with poor healthcare outcomes in older people, but maintaining mobility is frequently compromised due to time pressures experienced by clinical staff. Volunteers are established in many hospitals, usually involved in indirect patient care. Recent evidence suggests that trained mealtime volunteers had a positive impact on patients and hospital staff. It is unclear whether volunteers can help older inpatients to mobilise.
Systematic review.
We searched Cochrane, Medline, Embase, CINAHL, AMED and Google databases using MeSH headings and keywords within six key themes: inpatients, older, mobility/exercise, delirium, falls and volunteers. Full texts of relevant articles were retrieved and reference lists reviewed.
Of the 2428 articles that were identified, two scientific studies and three reports on quality improvement initiatives were included in the final review. One study included volunteer assisted mobilisation as part of a delirium prevention intervention (HELP). The second study has not reported yet (MOVE ON). The contribution of volunteers in both is unclear. Three quality improvement initiatives trained volunteers to help mobilise patients. They were not formally evaluated but report positive effects of the volunteers on patient and staff satisfaction.
This review has identified a lack of scientific evidence for the use of volunteers in mobilising older medical inpatients, but quality improvement initiatives suggest that volunteers can be employed in this role with reports of staff and patient satisfaction: this is an area for further development and evaluation.
This review outlines the evidence for the involvement of volunteers in maintaining patients' mobility, identifies mobilisation protocols that have been used, the need to train volunteers and for formal evaluation of volunteers in this role. Prospero registration number: CRD42014010388.
回顾当前关于使用志愿者动员老年急性内科住院患者的证据。
住院期间的活动受限与老年人不良的医疗保健结果相关,但由于临床工作人员面临的时间压力,维持活动能力常常受到影响。许多医院都设有志愿者,他们通常参与间接的患者护理工作。最近的证据表明,经过培训的用餐时间志愿者对患者和医院工作人员有积极影响。目前尚不清楚志愿者是否能帮助老年住院患者活动。
系统评价。
我们使用医学主题词和六个关键主题(住院患者、老年人、活动/锻炼、谵妄、跌倒和志愿者)中的关键词搜索了Cochrane、Medline、Embase、CINAHL、AMED和谷歌数据库。检索了相关文章的全文并查阅了参考文献列表。
在识别出的2428篇文章中,最终评价纳入了两项科学研究和三份关于质量改进举措的报告。一项研究将志愿者协助活动作为谵妄预防干预措施(HELP)的一部分。第二项研究尚未报告结果(MOVE ON)。两项研究中志愿者的贡献均不明确。三项质量改进举措对志愿者进行了培训,以帮助患者活动。这些举措未进行正式评估,但报告称志愿者对患者和工作人员满意度有积极影响。
本评价发现缺乏关于使用志愿者动员老年内科住院患者的科学证据,但质量改进举措表明,志愿者可担任这一角色,且有工作人员和患者满意度的报告:这是一个有待进一步发展和评估的领域。
本评价概述了志愿者参与维持患者活动能力的证据,确定了已采用的活动方案,培训志愿者的必要性以及对担任这一角色的志愿者进行正式评估的必要性。Prospero注册号:CRD42014010388。