Périé Catherine, de Blois Sylvie
Direction de la Recherche Forestière, Ministère des Forêts, de la Faune et des Parcs , Québec , Canada.
Department of Plant Science, Macdonald Campus, McGill University, Ste-Anne-de-Bellevue, Quebec, Canada; McGill School of Environment, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
PeerJ. 2016 Jul 13;4:e2218. doi: 10.7717/peerj.2218. eCollection 2016.
Projecting suitable conditions for a species as a function of future climate provides a reasonable, although admittedly imperfect, spatially explicit estimate of species vulnerability associated with climate change. Projections emphasizing range shifts at continental scale, however, can mask contrasting patterns at local or regional scale where management and policy decisions are made. Moreover, models usually show potential for areas to become climatically unsuitable, remain suitable, or become suitable for a particular species with climate change, but each of these outcomes raises markedly different ecological and management issues. Managing forest decline at sites where climatic stress is projected to increase is likely to be the most immediate challenge resulting from climate change. Here we assess habitat suitability with climate change for five dominant tree species of eastern North American forests, focusing on areas of greatest vulnerability (loss of suitability in the baseline range) in Quebec (Canada) rather than opportunities (increase in suitability). Results show that these species are at risk of maladaptation over a remarkably large proportion of their baseline range. Depending on species, 5-21% of currently climatically suitable habitats are projected to be at risk of becoming unsuitable. This suggests that species that have traditionally defined whole regional vegetation assemblages could become less adapted to these regions, with significant impact on ecosystems and forest economy. In spite of their well-recognised limitations and the uncertainty that remains, regionally-explicit risk assessment approaches remain one of the best options to convey that message and the need for climate policies and forest management adaptation strategies.
根据未来气候预测某一物种的适宜条件,能提供一个合理的、尽管公认并不完美的、关于与气候变化相关的物种脆弱性的空间明确估计。然而,强调大陆尺度范围变化的预测可能会掩盖在做出管理和政策决策的地方或区域尺度上的不同模式。此外,模型通常显示出随着气候变化,某些地区可能变得气候不适宜、保持适宜或变得适宜于某一特定物种,但这些结果中的每一个都会引发明显不同的生态和管理问题。在预计气候压力会增加的地区管理森林衰退可能是气候变化带来的最直接挑战。在此,我们评估了北美东部森林中五种主要树种在气候变化下的栖息地适宜性,重点关注加拿大魁北克最脆弱的地区(基线范围内适宜性丧失),而非机会地区(适宜性增加)。结果表明,这些物种在其基线范围的很大一部分面临适应不良的风险。根据物种不同,预计目前气候适宜的栖息地中有5% - 21%有变得不适宜的风险。这表明,传统上定义整个区域植被组合的物种可能会对这些区域的适应性降低,对生态系统和森林经济产生重大影响。尽管存在公认的局限性和仍然存在的不确定性,但区域明确的风险评估方法仍然是传达这一信息以及气候政策和森林管理适应战略需求的最佳选择之一。