Manning Victoria, Staiger Petra K, Hall Kate, Garfield Joshua B B, Flaks Gabriella, Leung Daniel, Hughes Laura K, Lum Jarrad A G, Lubman Dan I, Verdejo-Garcia Antonio
Turning Point, Eastern Health, Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia.
Eastern Health Clinical School, Monash University, Box Hill, Victoria, Australia.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2016 Sep;40(9):2011-9. doi: 10.1111/acer.13163. Epub 2016 Aug 4.
Relapse is common in alcohol-dependent individuals and can be triggered by alcohol-related cues in the environment. It has been suggested that these individuals develop cognitive biases, in which cues automatically capture attention and elicit an approach action tendency that promotes alcohol seeking. The study aim was to examine whether cognitive bias modification (CBM) training targeting approach bias could be delivered during residential alcohol detoxification and improve treatment outcomes.
Using a 2-group parallel-block (ratio 1:1) randomized controlled trial with allocation concealed to the outcome assessor, 83 alcohol-dependent inpatients received either 4 sessions of CBM training where participants were implicitly trained to make avoidance movements in response to pictures of alcoholic beverages and approach movements in response to pictures of nonalcoholic beverages, or 4 sessions of sham training (controls) delivered over 4 consecutive days during the 7-day detoxification program. The primary outcome measure was continuous abstinence at 2 weeks postdischarge. Secondary outcomes included time to relapse, frequency and quantity of alcohol consumption, and craving. Outcomes were assessed in a telephonic follow-up interview.
Seventy-one (85%) participants were successfully followed up, of whom 61 completed all 4 training sessions. With an intention-to-treat approach, there was a trend for higher abstinence rates in the CBM group relative to controls (69 vs. 47%, p = 0.07); however, a per-protocol analysis revealed significantly higher abstinence rates among participants completing 4 sessions of CBM relative to controls (75 vs. 45%, p = 0.02). Craving score, time to relapse, mean drinking days, and mean standard drinks per drinking day did not differ significantly between the groups.
This is the first trial demonstrating the feasibility of CBM delivered during alcohol detoxification and supports earlier research suggesting it may be a useful, low-cost adjunctive treatment to improve treatment outcomes for alcohol-dependent patients.
酒精依赖个体中复发很常见,且可由环境中与酒精相关的线索触发。有人提出,这些个体形成了认知偏差,即线索会自动吸引注意力并引发一种趋近行动倾向,从而促进对酒精的寻求。本研究的目的是检验针对趋近偏差的认知偏差修正(CBM)训练是否可以在住院酒精戒断期间进行,并改善治疗效果。
采用两组平行分组(比例1:1)随机对照试验,结果评估者不知道分组情况,83名酒精依赖住院患者接受4次CBM训练,在此过程中参与者被隐性训练对酒精饮料图片做出回避动作,对非酒精饮料图片做出趋近动作,或者在为期7天的戒断计划中连续4天接受4次假训练(对照组)。主要结局指标是出院后2周的持续戒酒情况。次要结局包括复发时间、饮酒频率和饮酒量以及渴望程度。结局通过电话随访访谈进行评估。
71名(85%)参与者成功完成随访,其中61名完成了全部4次训练课程。采用意向性分析方法,CBM组的戒酒率相对于对照组有升高趋势(69%对47%,p = 0.07);然而,符合方案分析显示,完成4次CBM训练的参与者的戒酒率相对于对照组显著更高(75%对45%,p = 0.02)。两组之间的渴望评分、复发时间、平均饮酒天数以及每个饮酒日的平均标准饮酒量没有显著差异。
这是第一项证明在酒精戒断期间进行CBM可行性的试验,并支持早期研究,表明其可能是一种有用的、低成本的辅助治疗方法,可改善酒精依赖患者的治疗效果。