Snedden Traci R, Brooks Margaret Alison, Hetzel Scott, McGuine Tim
*School of Nursing, University of Wisconsin-Madison; Departments of †Orthopedics; and ‡Pediatrics, School of Medicine and Public Health, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI; and §Biostatistics and Medical Informatics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI.
Clin J Sport Med. 2017 Sep;27(5):462-467. doi: 10.1097/JSM.0000000000000389.
Establish sex, age, and concussion history-specific normative baseline sport concussion assessment tool 3 (SCAT3) values in adolescent athletes.
Prospective cohort.
Seven Wisconsin high schools.
Seven hundred fifty-eight high school athletes participating in 19 sports.
Sex, age, and concussion history.
Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 3 (SCAT3): total number of symptoms; symptom severity; total Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC); and each SAC component (orientation, immediate memory, concentration, delayed recall); Balance Error Scoring System (BESS) total errors (BESS, floor and foam pad).
Males reported a higher total number of symptoms [median (interquartile range): 0 (0-2) vs 0 (0-1), P = 0.001] and severity of symptoms [0 (0-3) vs 0 (0-2), P = 0.001] and a lower mean (SD) total SAC [26.0 (2.3) vs 26.4 (2.0), P = 0.026], and orientation [5 (4-5) vs 5 (5-5), P = 0.021]. There was no difference in baseline scores between sex for immediate memory, concentration, delayed recall or BESS total errors. No differences were found for any test domain based on age. Previously, concussed athletes reported a higher total number of symptoms [1 (0-4) vs 0 (0-2), P = 0.001] and symptom severity [2 (0-5) vs 0 (0-2), P = 0.001]. BESS total scores did not differ by concussion history.
This study represents the first published normative baseline SCAT3 values in high school athletes. Results varied by sex and history of previous concussion but not by age. The normative baseline values generated from this study will help clinicians better evaluate and interpret SCAT3 results of concussed adolescent athletes.
建立青少年运动员基于性别、年龄和脑震荡病史的运动性脑震荡评估工具3(SCAT3)的特定规范基线值。
前瞻性队列研究。
威斯康星州的7所高中。
758名参加19项运动的高中运动员。
性别、年龄和脑震荡病史。
运动性脑震荡评估工具3(SCAT3):症状总数;症状严重程度;标准化脑震荡评估(SAC)总分;以及每个SAC分量表(定向力、即刻记忆、注意力、延迟回忆);平衡误差评分系统(BESS)总误差(BESS,地面和泡沫垫)。
男性报告的症状总数更多[中位数(四分位间距):0(0 - 2)对0(0 - 1),P = 0.001]、症状严重程度更高[0(0 - 3)对0(0 - 2),P = 0.001],SAC总分更低[均值(标准差)26.0(2.3)对26.4(2.0),P = 0.026],定向力分量表得分更低[5(4 - 5)对`5(5 - 5),P = 0.021]。即刻记忆、注意力、延迟回忆或BESS总误差在性别间的基线得分无差异。基于年龄,各测试领域均未发现差异。既往有脑震荡的运动员报告的症状总数更多[1(0 - 4)对0(0 - 2),P = 0.001]、症状严重程度更高[2(0 - 5)对0(0 - 2),P = 0.001]。BESS总分在有无脑震荡病史的运动员中无差异。
本研究首次公布了高中运动员SCAT3的规范基线值。结果因性别和既往脑震荡病史而异,但不因年龄而异。本研究生成的规范基线值将有助于临床医生更好地评估和解读脑震荡青少年运动员的SCAT3结果。