Meisel Samuel N, Colder Craig R, Read Jennifer P
Department of Psychology, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York, Buffalo, New York.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2016 Oct;40(10):2218-2228. doi: 10.1111/acer.13202. Epub 2016 Sep 12.
Informed by inconsistent findings regarding the association between injunctive norms (IN) and drinking behaviors, the current study developed a new measure of IN, the Injunctive Norms Drinking and Abstaining Behaviors Questionnaire (IN-DABQ). This measure addressed several psychometric weaknesses of prior assessment of this construct, specifically, reliance on single-item measures, and assessment of a limited range of drinking behaviors. The new measure also assessed norms for reasons for abstaining from drinking as college students often have simultaneous motives to use and inhibit their drug use. A parallel measure of descriptive norms (DN), the Descriptive Norms Drinking and Abstaining Behaviors Questionnaire (DN-DABQ), was created to allow for a comparison of the relative predictive effects of descriptive and IN in relation to different drinking outcomes.
A college sample (N = 254, female = 50.42%) was recruited using Amazon's Mechanical Turk. Participants completed an online survey assessing demographic characteristics, social norms for 3 referents, weekly alcohol use, and alcohol-related consequences.
Exploratory factor analyses indicated 2 factors for the DN-DABQ and 3 factors for the IN-DABQ. The IN Drinking Behaviors factor consistently predicted weekly consumption and alcohol-related consequences across 3 reference groups (typical college student at your school, friends, and closest friends).
These findings suggest that prior inconsistencies in the relationship between IN and drinking behaviors are likely a function of poor measurement of this construct. Implications for normative feedback interventions are discussed.
鉴于关于禁令性规范(IN)与饮酒行为之间关联的研究结果不一致,本研究开发了一种新的IN测量方法,即禁令性规范饮酒与戒酒行为问卷(IN-DABQ)。该测量方法解决了此前对这一构念评估中的几个心理测量学弱点,具体而言,此前评估依赖单项目测量,且对饮酒行为的评估范围有限。新的测量方法还评估了戒酒原因的规范,因为大学生往往同时有饮酒和抑制饮酒的动机。同时创建了一种描述性规范(DN)的平行测量方法,即描述性规范饮酒与戒酒行为问卷(DN-DABQ),以便比较描述性规范和禁令性规范对不同饮酒结果的相对预测效果。
通过亚马逊的Mechanical Turk招募了一个大学生样本(N = 254,女性占50.42%)。参与者完成了一项在线调查,评估人口统计学特征、针对3个参照对象的社会规范、每周饮酒情况以及与酒精相关的后果。
探索性因素分析表明,DN-DABQ有2个因素,IN-DABQ有3个因素。IN饮酒行为因素在3个参照群体(你所在学校的典型大学生、朋友和最亲密的朋友)中始终能预测每周饮酒量及与酒精相关的后果。
这些发现表明,此前IN与饮酒行为之间关系的不一致可能是由于对这一构念的测量不佳所致。文中讨论了对规范性反馈干预的启示。