Akseer Nadia, Bhatti Zaid, Rizvi Arjumand, Salehi Ahmad S, Mashal Taufiq, Bhutta Zulfiqar A
Centre for Global Child Health, Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
BMC Public Health. 2016 Sep 12;16 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):797. doi: 10.1186/s12889-016-3406-1.
Afghanistan has made considerable gains in improving maternal and child health and survival since 2001. However, socioeconomic and regional inequities may pose a threat to reaching universal coverage of health interventions and further health progress. We explored coverage and socioeconomic inequalities in key life-saving reproductive, maternal, newborn and child health (RMNCH) interventions at the national level and by region in Afghanistan. We also assessed gains in child survival through scaling up effective community-based interventions across wealth groups.
Using data from the Afghanistan Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) 2010/11, we explored 11 interventions that spanned all stages of the continuum of care, including indicators of composite coverage. Asset-based wealth quintiles were constructed using standardised methods, and absolute inequalities were explored using wealth quintile (Q) gaps (Q5-Q1) and the slope index of inequality (SII), while relative inequalities were assessed with ratios (Q5/Q1) and the concentration index (CIX). The lives saved tool (LiST) modeling used to estimate neonatal and post-neonatal deaths averted from scaling up essential community-based interventions by 90 % coverage by 2025. Analyses considered the survey design characteristics and were conducted via STATA version 12.0 and SAS version 9.4.
Our results underscore significant pro-rich socioeconomic absolute and relative inequalities, and mass population deprivation across most all RMNCH interventions studied. The most inequitable are antenatal care with a skilled attendant (ANCS), skilled birth attendance (SBA), and 4 or more antenatal care visits (ANC4) where the richest have between 3.0 and 5.6 times higher coverage relative to the poor, and Q5-Q1 gaps range from 32 % - 65 %. Treatment of sick children and breastfeeding interventions are the most equitably distributed. Across regions, inequalities were highest in the more urbanised East, West and Central regions of the country, while they were lowest in the South and Southeast. About 7700 newborns and 26,000 post-neonates could be saved by scaling up coverage of community outreach interventions to 90 %, with the most gains in the poorest quintiles.
Afghanistan is a pervasively poor and conflict-prone nation that has only recently experienced a decade of relative stability. Though donor investments during this period have been plentiful and have contributed to rebuilding of health infrastructure in the country, glaring inequities remain. A resolution to scaling up health coverage in insecure and isolated regions, and improving accessibility for the poorest and marginalised populations, should be at the forefront of national policy and programming efforts.
自2001年以来,阿富汗在改善孕产妇和儿童健康及生存状况方面取得了显著进展。然而,社会经济和地区不平等可能对实现卫生干预措施的全民覆盖以及进一步的健康进步构成威胁。我们在阿富汗全国及各地区探讨了关键的挽救生命的生殖、孕产妇、新生儿和儿童健康(RMNCH)干预措施的覆盖情况及社会经济不平等问题。我们还评估了通过在不同财富群体中扩大有效的社区干预措施来提高儿童生存率所取得的成效。
利用2010/11年阿富汗多指标类集调查(MICS)的数据,我们探讨了涵盖连续护理所有阶段的11项干预措施,包括综合覆盖指标。采用标准化方法构建基于资产的财富五分位数,并使用财富五分位数差距(Q5-Q1)和不平等斜率指数(SII)来探讨绝对不平等,同时使用比率(Q5/Q1)和集中指数(CIX)来评估相对不平等。生命挽救工具(LiST)模型用于估计到2025年将基本社区干预措施的覆盖率提高90%可避免的新生儿和新生儿后期死亡人数。分析考虑了调查设计特征,并通过STATA 12.0版和SAS 9.4版进行。
我们的结果凸显了在社会经济方面显著的有利于富人的绝对和相对不平等,以及在几乎所有研究的RMNCH干预措施中普遍存在的人口贫困状况。最不平等的是有熟练医护人员陪伴的产前护理(ANCS)、熟练接生(SBA)以及4次或更多次产前护理就诊(ANC4),最富裕人群的覆盖率相对于贫困人口高出3.0至5.6倍,Q5-Q1差距在32%至65%之间。患病儿童的治疗和母乳喂养干预措施分布最为公平。在各地区中,不平等程度在该国城市化程度较高的东部、西部和中部地区最高,而在南部和东南部最低。通过将社区外展干预措施的覆盖率提高到90%,大约可挽救7700名新生儿和26000名新生儿后期儿童,最贫困五分位数人群受益最大。
阿富汗是一个普遍贫困且容易发生冲突的国家,直到最近才经历了十年的相对稳定。尽管在此期间捐助者的投资丰富,并为该国卫生基础设施的重建做出了贡献,但明显的不平等现象仍然存在。扩大不安全和偏远地区的卫生覆盖范围以及改善最贫困和边缘化人群的可及性,应成为国家政策和规划工作的首要任务。