Cerciello Milena, Isella Valeria, Proserpi Alice, Papagno Costanza
Department of Psychology, University of Milano Bicocca, Piazza dell'Ateneo Nuovo, U6- 3170 d, Milan, Italy.
Neurology Section of San Gerardo Hospital, Monza, Italy.
Neurol Sci. 2017 Jan;38(1):115-122. doi: 10.1007/s10072-016-2722-7. Epub 2016 Sep 26.
Alzheimer's disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD) and frontotemporal dementia (FTD) are the most common forms of dementia. It is well known that memory deficits in AD are different from those in VaD and FTD, especially with respect to cued recall. The aim of this clinical study was to compare the memory performance in 15 AD, 10 VaD and 9 FTD patients and 20 normal controls by means of a 24-item Grober-Buschke test [8]. The patients' groups were comparable in terms of severity of dementia. We considered free and total recall (free plus cued) both in immediate and delayed recall and computed an Index of Sensitivity to Cueing (ISC) [8] for immediate and delayed trials. We assessed whether cued recall predicted the subsequent free recall across our patients' groups. We found that AD patients recalled fewer items from the beginning and were less sensitive to cueing supporting the hypothesis that memory disorders in AD depend on encoding and storage deficit. In immediate recall VaD and FTD showed a similar memory performance and a stronger sensitivity to cueing than AD, suggesting that memory disorders in these patients are due to a difficulty in spontaneously implementing efficient retrieval strategies. However, we found a lower ISC in the delayed recall compared to the immediate trials in VaD than FTD due to a higher forgetting in VaD.
阿尔茨海默病(AD)、血管性痴呆(VaD)和额颞叶痴呆(FTD)是痴呆最常见的形式。众所周知,AD患者的记忆缺陷与VaD和FTD患者不同,尤其是在线索回忆方面。本临床研究的目的是通过一项包含24个条目的格罗贝尔-布施克测试[8],比较15例AD患者、10例VaD患者、9例FTD患者以及20名正常对照者的记忆表现。各患者组在痴呆严重程度方面具有可比性。我们在即时回忆和延迟回忆中均考虑了自由回忆和总回忆(自由回忆加线索回忆),并计算了即时和延迟试验的线索敏感性指数(ISC)[8]。我们评估了线索回忆是否能预测我们患者组随后的自由回忆。我们发现,AD患者从一开始回忆的条目就较少,且对线索的敏感性较低,这支持了AD患者的记忆障碍取决于编码和存储缺陷这一假设。在即时回忆中,VaD和FTD患者表现出相似的记忆表现,且比AD患者对线索的敏感性更强,这表明这些患者的记忆障碍是由于难以自发地实施有效的检索策略。然而,我们发现,与即时试验相比,VaD患者在延迟回忆中的ISC低于FTD患者,这是因为VaD患者的遗忘率更高。