Mutter Andrew F, Cooke Alexandra B, Saleh Olivier, Gomez Yessica-Haydee, Daskalopoulou Stella S
Division of Experimental Medicine, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Division of Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University Health Centre, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Hypertens Res. 2017 Feb;40(2):146-172. doi: 10.1038/hr.2016.111. Epub 2016 Oct 13.
The objective of this systematic review was to provide insight into the controversy that still abounds as to the impact of acute aerobic exercise on immediate changes in arterial stiffness. Electronic databases were searched to identify articles assessing the effects of acute aerobic exercise on parameters of arterial stiffness. Eligible studies included arterial stiffness measurements before and after acute aerobic exercise in healthy human subjects. Forty-three studies were included. The effect of acute aerobic exercise on arterial stiffness was found to be dependent on the anatomical segment assessed, and on the timing of the measurement post-exercise. Arterial stiffness of the central and upper body peripheral arterial segments was found to be increased relative to resting values immediately post-exercise (0-5 min), whereas, thereafter (>5 min), decreased to a level at or below resting values. In the lower limbs, proximal to the primary working muscles, arterial stiffness decreased immediately post-exercise (0-5 min), which persisted into the recovery period post-exercise (>5 min). This systematic review reveals a differential response to acute exercise in the lower and upper/central arterial segments in healthy adult subjects. We further showed that the effect of acute aerobic exercise on arterial stiffness is dependent on the timing of the measurements post-exercise. Therefore, when assessing the overall impact of exercise on arterial stiffness, it is important to consider the arterial segment being analyzed and measurement time point, as failure to contextualize the measurement can lead to conflicting results and misleading clinical inferences.
本系统评价的目的是深入了解关于急性有氧运动对动脉僵硬度即时变化的影响仍存在的争议。检索电子数据库以识别评估急性有氧运动对动脉僵硬度参数影响的文章。符合条件的研究包括健康人类受试者急性有氧运动前后的动脉僵硬度测量。共纳入43项研究。发现急性有氧运动对动脉僵硬度的影响取决于所评估的解剖节段以及运动后测量的时间。发现中央和上身外周动脉节段的动脉僵硬度在运动后即刻(0 - 5分钟)相对于静息值增加,而此后(>5分钟),降至静息值或低于静息值的水平。在下肢,靠近主要工作肌肉的部位,动脉僵硬度在运动后即刻(0 - 5分钟)下降,并持续到运动后的恢复期(>5分钟)。本系统评价揭示了健康成年受试者下肢和上/中央动脉节段对急性运动的不同反应。我们进一步表明,急性有氧运动对动脉僵硬度的影响取决于运动后测量的时间。因此,在评估运动对动脉僵硬度的总体影响时,重要的是要考虑所分析的动脉节段和测量时间点,因为未能将测量置于具体情境中可能导致相互矛盾的结果和误导性的临床推断。