Ding Weihua, Chen Shuping, Wang Rong, Cai Jun, Cheng Yuan, Yu Liang, Li Qinghua, Deng Fang, Zhu Shengmei, Yu Wenhua
Department of Anesthesia & Pain Medicine, The First Affiliated Hospital of Medical School of Zhejiang University Pain Clinic, Hangzhou First People's Hospital, Nanjing Medical University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, P.R. China Pain Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA Department of Radiology Department of Neurosurgery, Hangzhou First People's Hospital, Nanjing Medical University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, P.R. China.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2016 Oct;95(40):e4940. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000004940.
Percutaneous radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFT) of the Gasserian ganglion is an effective treatment for primary trigeminal neuralgia (pTN). Currently Hartel anterior approach is the most commonly used method to access the Gasserian ganglion. However, this approach is associated with high recurrence rate and technical difficulties in certain patients with foramen ovale (FO) anatomical variations. In the present study, we assessed the feasibility of accessing the Gasserian ganglion through the FO from a mandibular angle under computed tomography (CT) and neuronavigation guidance.A total of 108 patients with TN were randomly divided into 2 groups (Group G and Group H) using a random number table. In Group H, Hartel anterior approach was used to puncture the FO; whereas in Group G, a percutaneous puncture through a mandibular angle was used to reach the FO. In both groups, procedures were guided by CT imaging and neuronavigation. The success rates, therapeutic effects, complications, and recurrence rates of the 2 groups were compared.The puncture success rates in Group H and Group G were 52/54 (96.30%) and 49/54 (90.74%), respectively (P = 0.24). The 2 procedural failures in Group H were rescued by using submandibular trajectory, and the 5 failures in Group G were successfully reapproached by Hartel method. Therapeutic effects as measured by Barrow Neurological Institute (BNI) pain scale (P = 0.03) and quality of life (QOL) scores (P = 0.04) were significantly better in Group G than those in Group H at 36 months posttreatment. Hematoma developed in 1/54 (1.85%) cases in Group H, and no cases of hematoma were observed in Group G (P = 0.33). In Group H, RFT resulted in injury to the unintended trigeminal nerve branches and motor fibers in 27/52 (51.92%) cases; in Group G, it resulted in the same type of injury in 7/49 cases (14.29%) (P < 0.01). In Group H, the 24- and 36-month recurrence rates were 12/51 (23.53%) and 20/51 (39.22%), respectively; in Group G, these recurrence rates were 7/49 (12.24%) and 9/49 (16.33%, P = 0.03), respectively.CT- and neuronavigation-guided puncture from a mandibular angle through the FO into the Gasserian ganglion can be safely and effectively used to deliver RFT for the treatment of pTN. This method may represent a viable option to treat TN in addition to Hartel approach.
经皮半月神经节射频热凝术(RFT)是原发性三叉神经痛(pTN)的一种有效治疗方法。目前,Hartel前路是最常用的进入半月神经节的方法。然而,这种方法在某些卵圆孔(FO)解剖变异的患者中与高复发率和技术困难相关。在本研究中,我们评估了在计算机断层扫描(CT)和神经导航引导下经下颌角通过卵圆孔进入半月神经节的可行性。
使用随机数字表将108例TN患者随机分为2组(G组和H组)。在H组中,采用Hartel前路穿刺卵圆孔;而在G组中,采用经下颌角的经皮穿刺到达卵圆孔。两组均在CT成像和神经导航引导下进行操作。比较两组的成功率、治疗效果、并发症和复发率。
H组和G组的穿刺成功率分别为52/54(96.30%)和49/54(90.74%)(P = 0.24)。H组的2例操作失败通过使用下颌下路径挽救,G组的5例失败通过Hartel方法成功重新穿刺。在治疗后36个月,根据巴罗神经学研究所(BNI)疼痛量表(P = 0.03)和生活质量(QOL)评分(P = 0.04)测量,G组的治疗效果明显优于H组。H组1/54(1.85%)例出现血肿,G组未观察到血肿病例(P = 0.33)。在H组中,RFT导致27/52(51.92%)例意外的三叉神经分支和运动纤维损伤;在G组中,7/49例(14.29%)出现相同类型的损伤(P < 0.01)。在H组中,24个月和36个月的复发率分别为12/51(23.53%)和20/51(39.22%);在G组中,这些复发率分别为7/49(12.24%)和9/49(16.33%,P = 0.03)。
CT和神经导航引导下经下颌角通过卵圆孔进入半月神经节可安全有效地用于进行RFT治疗pTN。除Hartel方法外,该方法可能是治疗TN的一种可行选择。