Karabudak Efsun, Koksal Eda
Department of Nutrition and Dietetics. Faculty of Health Sciences. Gazi University. Ankara, Turkey.
Nutr Hosp. 2016 Sep 20;33(5):577. doi: 10.20960/nh.577.
The purpose of this investigation is to test the validity and reliability the assessment methods for the true beverage consumption of adults.
This cross-sectional study was carried out 291 healthy volunteers. The beverage intake questionnaire (BIQ) was prepared in combination with a new one which is developed based on basic principles and the existing one developed for the beverages consumed the most with respect to frequency and amount by Turkish populations. During the initial visit the participants completed BIQ1 and then provided a urine sample to determine urinary specific gravity(USG). For validity, participants recorded the type and quantity of foods and beverages consumed on the same day and previous two days. Two weeks later, for reliability, participants completed the same beverage intake questionnaire (BIQ2).
Mean daily total fluid intake was estimated at 1,773 ± 49.4mL using the dietary intake record (DIR), 2,120 ± 49.5 mL with BIQ1 and 1,990 ± 46.3 mL for BIQ2. The largest contribution to total fluid intake was plain water. The response on the two assessment tools (DIR and BIQ1) all beverage intakes were significantly correlated (p < 0.01) except for alcoholic beverage intake. One could see a significant correlation between BIQ1 and BIQ2 in relation to total fluid intakes (r = 0.838,p < 0.01). The USG measurement was negatively correlated with three assessment tools (DIR, BIQ1 and BIQ2), the amount of plain water and the amount of total fluid intake.
The self-administered instrument described in this study may be useful for researchers interested in assessing habitual beverage consumption patterns or evaluating hydration status for adults.
本调查旨在检验成人真实饮料摄入量评估方法的有效性和可靠性。
本横断面研究对291名健康志愿者进行。结合基于基本原则开发的新问卷和针对土耳其人群消费频率和消费量最高的饮料所开发的现有问卷,编制了饮料摄入问卷(BIQ)。在初次就诊时,参与者完成BIQ1,然后提供尿液样本以测定尿比重(USG)。为了验证有效性,参与者记录当天以及前两天食用的食物和饮料的种类和数量。两周后,为了评估可靠性,参与者完成相同的饮料摄入问卷(BIQ2)。
使用饮食摄入记录(DIR)估计每日平均总液体摄入量为1773±49.4毫升,BIQ1为2120±49.5毫升,BIQ2为1990±46.3毫升。对总液体摄入量贡献最大的是白开水。除酒精饮料摄入量外,两种评估工具(DIR和BIQ1)对所有饮料摄入量的回答均显著相关(p<0.01)。就总液体摄入量而言,BIQ1和BIQ2之间存在显著相关性(r=0.838,p<0.01)。USG测量值与三种评估工具(DIR、BIQ1和BIQ2)、白开水摄入量和总液体摄入量均呈负相关。
本研究中描述的自我管理工具可能对有兴趣评估成人习惯性饮料消费模式或评估水合状态的研究人员有用。