Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
School of Public Health and Health Systems, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON, Canada.
Nutr J. 2018 Aug 1;17(1):73. doi: 10.1186/s12937-018-0380-8.
The contribution of beverages to overall diet is of increasing interest to researchers and policymakers, particularly in terms of consumption of drinks high in added sugars; however, few tools to assess beverage intake have been developed and evaluated. This study aimed to evaluate the relative validity of a new online Beverage Frequency Questionnaire (BFQ) among young adults in Canada.
A cross-sectional relative validation study was conducted among young adults aged 16-30 years (n = 50). Participants completed a 17-item BFQ, a 7-day food record (7dFR), and a single-item measure of sugary drink intake. Pearson correlations and paired t-tests were used to evaluate correlation and agreement between the measures for 17 individual beverage categories, total drink consumption, total alcoholic beverage consumption, and two definitions of drinks with excess sugars. Cognitive interviews were conducted to examine participant interpretation and comprehensiveness of the BFQ.
Estimates of beverage intake based on the BFQ and the 7dFR were highly correlated, specifically for the total number and volume of beverages consumed, total alcoholic beverage consumption, sugary drink intake, and each of the 17 beverage categories with 3 exceptions: coffee or tea with sugar or cream, specialty coffees, and hard alcohol with caloric mix. Paired t-tests between the BFQ and the 7dFR indicated that the average reported volume was significantly different only for sweetened fruit drinks. The single-item measure of sugary beverage intake was not significantly correlated with the 7dFR. Cognitive interviewing demonstrated high comprehension levels, and confirmed the appropriateness of the BFQ beverage categories and sizes.
Overall, the results suggest that the BFQ performed well relative to a 7dFR and had high usability among this study population, indicating its promise for collecting population-level data on beverage intake, including sugar-sweetened beverages, which are known indicators of diet and health.
饮料在整体饮食中的作用越来越受到研究人员和政策制定者的关注,尤其是在高添加糖饮料的消费方面;然而,开发和评估的饮料摄入量评估工具却很少。本研究旨在评估一种新的在线饮料频率问卷(BFQ)在加拿大年轻成年人中的相对有效性。
对年龄在 16-30 岁的年轻人进行了一项横断面相对验证研究(n=50)。参与者完成了 17 项 BFQ、7 天食物记录(7dFR)和一份含糖饮料摄入量的单项测量。使用 Pearson 相关系数和配对 t 检验评估了 17 种饮料类别、总饮料摄入量、总酒精饮料摄入量和两种含有过量糖的饮料定义的测量值之间的相关性和一致性。进行认知访谈以检查 BFQ 的参与者解释和全面性。
基于 BFQ 和 7dFR 的饮料摄入量估计值高度相关,特别是对于总饮料数量和量、总酒精饮料摄入量、含糖饮料摄入量以及 17 种饮料类别的每一种,有 3 个例外:加糖或奶油的咖啡或茶、特种咖啡和含热量混合的烈性酒。BFQ 和 7dFR 之间的配对 t 检验表明,仅对于甜果饮料,报告的平均体积差异具有统计学意义。含糖饮料摄入的单项测量与 7dFR 无显著相关性。认知访谈表明理解水平较高,并证实了 BFQ 饮料类别和大小的适当性。
总体而言,结果表明 BFQ 与 7dFR 相比表现良好,并且在该研究人群中具有较高的可用性,表明其有望收集关于饮料摄入量的人群数据,包括含糖饮料,这些都是饮食和健康的已知指标。