Koerich Leonardo, Weissheimer André, de Menezes Luciane Macedo, Lindauer Steven J
Angle Orthod. 2017 May;87(3):473-479. doi: 10.2319/072316-574.1. Epub 2016 Oct 21.
To evaluate the precision and reproducibility of a protocol to perform rapid voxel-based superimposition of the mandible in growing patients using CBCT.
The sample comprised two cone-beam computed tomography scans taken at least 1 year apart from each of 24 growing patients. Voxel-based superimposition was performed by two examiners independently. The internal part of the symphysis extending to the first molar was used as the reference. The superimposition process took approximately 5 minutes. Once the mandibles were superimposed, surface models were created and root mean square (RMS) changes were obtained by means of iterative closest point. To evaluate precision, differences in three areas were measured between time point 1 (T1) and time point 2 (T2) superimposed. To evaluate reproducibility between different examiners, the distances between T2 superimposed by each operator were measured in five different areas. Descriptive statistics were used to evaluate the precision of the superimposition and the interexaminer reproducibility measurements for each case were reported individually.
The superimposition mean error between T1 and T2 for the right and left sides of the mandible and chin were 0.23 mm, 0.25 mm, and 0.33 mm, respectively. Interexaminer reproducibility error was ≤0.3 mm in 20 of 24 cases for measurements near the registration area. In the ramus area, two cases had errors >1 mm (1 mm-1.3 mm).
The rapid superimposition was precise for assessing dentoalveolar changes and structures close to the registration area. However, evaluation of the condyles and ramus area had limitations and needs improvement.
评估使用锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)对生长发育期患者下颌骨进行基于体素的快速叠加方案的精度和可重复性。
样本包括对24名生长发育期患者分别进行的两次间隔至少1年的锥形束计算机断层扫描。两名检查者独立进行基于体素的叠加。将耻骨联合延伸至第一磨牙的内部作为参考。叠加过程耗时约5分钟。下颌骨叠加后,创建表面模型,并通过迭代最近点法获得均方根(RMS)变化。为评估精度,测量叠加后的时间点1(T1)和时间点2(T2)之间三个区域的差异。为评估不同检查者之间的可重复性,在五个不同区域测量每位操作者叠加后的T2之间的距离。采用描述性统计评估叠加精度,并分别报告每个病例检查者间可重复性测量结果。
下颌骨左右两侧及颏部T1与T2之间的叠加平均误差分别为0.23mm、0.25mm和0.33mm。在靠近配准区域测量时,24例中有20例检查者间可重复性误差≤0.3mm。在升支区域,有两例误差>1mm(1mm - 1.3mm)。
快速叠加对于评估牙牙槽变化和靠近配准区域的结构是精确的。然而,髁突和升支区域的评估存在局限性,需要改进。