Happe Svenja, Evers Stefan, Thiedemann Christian, Bunten Sabine, Siegert Rudolf
Department of Neurology, Klinik Maria Frieden, Telgte, Germany; Institute of Clinical Neurophysiology, Klinikum Bremen-Ost/University of Göttingen, Germany.
Krankenhaus Lindenbrunn, Department of Neurology, Germany.
J Neurol Sci. 2016 Nov 15;370:7-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jns.2016.09.006. Epub 2016 Sep 9.
Treatment of restless legs syndrome (RLS) is primarily based on drugs. Since many patients report improvement of symptoms due to cooling their legs, we examined the efficacy of cryotherapy in RLS.
35 patients (28 women, 60.9±12.5years) with idiopathic RLS and symptoms starting not later than 6pm were randomized into three groups: cold air chamber at -60°C (n=12); cold air chamber at -10°C (n=12); local cryotherapy at -17°C (n=11). After a two week baseline, the different therapies were applied three minutes daily at 6pm over two weeks, followed by a four week observation period. The patients completed several questionnaires regarding RLS symptoms, sleep, and quality of life on a weekly basis (IRLS, ESS), VAS and sleep/morning protocol were completed daily, MOSS/RLS-QLI were completed once in each period. Additionally, the PLM index was measured by a mobile device at the end of baseline, intervention, and follow-up. The IRLS score was chosen as primary efficacy parameter.
At the end of follow-up, significant improvement of RLS symptoms and quality of life could be observed only in the -60°C group as compared to baseline (IRLS: p=0.009; RLS-QLI: p=0.006; ESS: p=0.020). Local cryotherapy led to improvement in quality of life (VAS4: p=0.028; RLS-QLI: p=0.014) and sleep quality (MOSS: p=0.020; MOSS2: p=0.022) but not in IRLS and ESS. In the -10°C group, the only significant effect was shortening of number of wake phases per night. Serious side-effects were not reported.
Whole body cryotherapy at -60°C and, to a less extent, local cryotherapy seem to be a treatment option for RLS in addition to conventional pharmacological treatment. However, the exact mode of cryotherapy needs to be established.
不安腿综合征(RLS)的治疗主要基于药物。由于许多患者报告称腿部降温后症状有所改善,我们研究了冷冻疗法对RLS的疗效。
35例(28名女性,年龄60.9±12.5岁)特发性RLS且症状开始时间不晚于下午6点的患者被随机分为三组:-60°C冷空气舱组(n = 12);-10°C冷空气舱组(n = 12);-17°C局部冷冻疗法组(n = 11)。经过两周的基线期后,不同疗法于下午6点每日应用三分钟,持续两周,随后是四周的观察期。患者每周完成几份关于RLS症状、睡眠和生活质量的问卷(国际不安腿综合征量表[IRLS]、爱泼沃斯思睡量表[ESS]),每日完成视觉模拟评分法(VAS)和睡眠/早晨记录,在每个阶段各完成一次医学结局研究睡眠量表(MOSS)/RLS生活质量指数(RLS-QLI)。此外,在基线期、干预期和随访结束时通过移动设备测量周期性肢体运动(PLM)指数。选择IRLS评分作为主要疗效参数。
随访结束时,与基线相比,仅-60°C组的RLS症状和生活质量有显著改善(IRLS:p = 0.009;RLS-QLI:p = 0.006;ESS:p = 0.020)。局部冷冻疗法使生活质量(VAS4:p = 0.028;RLS-QLI:p = 0.014)和睡眠质量(MOSS:p = 0.020;MOSS2:p = 0.022)得到改善,但IRLS和ESS未改善。在-10°C组,唯一显著的效果是缩短了每晚的觉醒次数。未报告严重的副作用。
除传统药物治疗外,-60°C全身冷冻疗法以及程度稍轻的局部冷冻疗法似乎是RLS的一种治疗选择。然而,冷冻疗法的确切作用方式有待确定。