Koizumi Masatoshi, Kim Jungho
Department of Linguistics, Graduate School of Arts and Letters, Tohoku University Sendai, Japan.
Department of Foreign Languages, Kyoto Women's University Kyoto, Japan.
Front Psychol. 2016 Oct 14;7:1541. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01541. eCollection 2016.
Cortical activations during the processing of Kaqchikel transitive sentences with canonical and non-canonical word orders were investigated using functional magnetic resonance imaging. Kaqchikel is an endangered Mayan language spoken in Guatemala. The word order in this language is relatively flexible. We observed higher cortical activations in the left inferior frontal gyrus for sentences with the subject-verb-object (SVO) word order, as compared to sentences with the verb-object-subject (VOS) word order, suggesting that Kaqchikel sentences are easier to process when they have the VOS order than when they have the SVO order. This supports the traditional analysis of Mayan word order: the syntactically simplest word order of transitive sentences in Mayan languages, including Kaqchikel, is VOS. More importantly, the results revealed that the subject-before-object word order preference in sentence comprehension, previously observed in other languages, might not reflect a universal aspect of human languages. Rather, processing preference may be language-specific to some extent, reflecting syntactic differences in individual languages.
利用功能磁共振成像技术,研究了卡克奇克尔语(Kaqchikel)中具有规范和非规范词序的及物句处理过程中的皮质激活情况。卡克奇克尔语是危地马拉一种濒危的玛雅语言。这种语言的词序相对灵活。与主谓宾(SVO)词序的句子相比,我们观察到主宾谓(VOS)词序的句子在左下额叶回有更高的皮质激活,这表明卡克奇克尔语句子的VOS词序比SVO词序更容易处理。这支持了对玛雅语词序的传统分析:包括卡克奇克尔语在内的玛雅语言中,及物句在句法上最简单的词序是VOS。更重要的是,结果表明,之前在其他语言中观察到的句子理解中主宾前词序偏好可能并不反映人类语言的普遍特征。相反,处理偏好可能在一定程度上是特定于语言的,反映了个别语言的句法差异。