Baumgartner C, Wessely P, Bingöl C, Maly J, Holzner F
Headache. 1989 Sep;29(8):510-4. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.1989.hed2908510.x.
We studied long-term prognosis and prognostic variables for therapeutic outcome of analgesic withdrawal in 54 patients with drug-induced headaches. The duration of headache history was 21.9 +/- 12.8 years. Each patient took an average of 38.8 +/- 22.8 tablets or suppositories a week and an average of 2.5 distinct drugs. Most patients used drugs containing several components. Caffeine was contained in at least one drug in all cases, ergotamine in 80.0% and pyrazolone in 77.1%. All patients were admitted to the hospital for two weeks. The analgesics were discontinued abruptly and the withdrawal symptoms were alleviated by neuroleptics and neurotropics. During the second week of hospital stay we started a basic therapy with calcium antagonists or beta blockers in patients suffering from migraine initially and with tricyclic antidepressants, physical therapy or biofeedback in patients suffering from tension type headaches initially. At the end of the study (mean follow-up period = 16.8 +/- 13.6 months) 38 patients (70.1%) were evaluated. 76.3% of these patients had significantly reduced their analgesic intake, 60.5% had experienced a significant relief of headache both in intensity and frequency, and 23.7% were therapeutic failures. Analysis of the time course of relapse revealed the first six months after hospital discharge as the critical period determining long-term success. The variables tested for prognostic relevance (age, sex, duration of headache history, number of tablets or suppositories taken a week, organic mental syndrome, and type of initial headaches) were not statistically significant.
我们研究了54例药物性头痛患者停用镇痛药后的长期预后及治疗结果的预后变量。头痛病史的持续时间为21.9±12.8年。每位患者每周平均服用38.8±22.8片或栓剂,平均使用2.5种不同的药物。大多数患者使用的药物含有多种成分。所有病例中至少有一种药物含有咖啡因,80.0%含有麦角胺,77.1%含有吡唑酮。所有患者住院两周。镇痛药突然停用,停用症状通过抗精神病药和神经营养药缓解。在住院的第二周,我们对最初患有偏头痛的患者开始使用钙拮抗剂或β受体阻滞剂进行基础治疗,对最初患有紧张型头痛的患者开始使用三环类抗抑郁药、物理治疗或生物反馈治疗。在研究结束时(平均随访期=16.8±13.6个月),对38例患者(70.1%)进行了评估。这些患者中有76.3%的镇痛药摄入量显著减少,60.5%的患者头痛强度和频率均有显著缓解,23.7%为治疗失败。对复发时间过程的分析显示,出院后的前六个月是决定长期成功的关键时期。所测试的与预后相关的变量(年龄、性别、头痛病史持续时间、每周服用的片剂或栓剂数量、器质性精神综合征以及初始头痛类型)无统计学意义。