College of Engineering, Swansea University, Bay Campus, Fabian Way, Swansea, SA1 8EN, UK.
Sci Eng Ethics. 2017 Dec;23(6):1487-1505. doi: 10.1007/s11948-016-9855-1. Epub 2016 Dec 19.
Individual athletes, coaches and sports teams seek continuously for ways to improve performance and accomplishment in elite competition. New techniques of performance analysis are a crucial part of the drive for athletic perfection. This paper discusses the ethical importance of one aspect of the future potential of performance analysis in sport, combining the field of biomedicine, sports engineering and nanotechnology in the form of 'Nanobiosensors'. This innovative technology has the potential to revolutionise sport, enabling real time biological data to be collected from athletes that can be electronically distributed. Enabling precise real time performance analysis is not without ethical problems. Arguments concerning (1) data ownership and privacy; (2) data confidentiality; and (3) athlete welfare are presented alongside a discussion of the use of the Precautionary Principle in making ethical evaluations. We conclude, that although the future potential use of Nanobiosensors in sports analysis offers many potential benefits, there is also a fear that it could be abused at a sporting system level. Hence, it is essential for sporting bodies to consider the development of a robust ethically informed governance framework in advance of their proliferated use.
个体运动员、教练和运动队一直在寻求提高精英比赛表现和成绩的方法。新的表现分析技术是追求运动完美的关键部分。本文讨论了未来运动表现分析潜力的一个方面的伦理重要性,将生物医学、体育工程和纳米技术领域结合在一起,形成了“纳米生物传感器”。这项创新技术有可能彻底改变运动,使运动员的实时生物数据能够被收集并通过电子方式进行分布。实现精确的实时表现分析并非没有伦理问题。本文就(1)数据所有权和隐私;(2)数据机密性;(3)运动员福利等问题进行了讨论,并对在进行伦理评估时使用预防原则进行了讨论。我们的结论是,尽管纳米生物传感器在运动分析中的未来潜在应用具有许多潜在的好处,但也担心它可能会在运动系统层面被滥用。因此,体育机构必须在广泛使用之前,考虑制定一个健全的、有伦理意识的治理框架。