Melina Giovanni, Angeloni Emiliano, Refice Simone, Benegiamo Cristian, Lechiancole Andrea, Matteucci Maria, Roscitano Antonino, Bianchini Roberto, Capuano Fabio, Comito Cosimo, Spitaleri Pietro, Tonelli Euclide, Speciale Giulio, Pristipino Christian, Monti Francesco, Serdoz Roberto, Paneni Francesco, Sinatra Riccardo
Department of Cardiac Surgery, Ospedale Sant'Andrea, Rome, Italy.
Catheterization Laboratory, Ospedale San Filippo Neri, Rome, Italy.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2017 Mar 1;51(3):547-553. doi: 10.1093/ejcts/ezw356.
To quantify residual coronary artery disease measured using the SYNTAX score (SS) and its relation to outcomes after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG).
We conducted a retrospective analysis on a consecutive series of 1608 patients [mean age 68 years, standard deviation (SD): 7, F:M, 242:1366] undergoing first-time isolated CABG from 2004 to 2015. The baseline SS was retrospectively determined from preoperative angiograms, and the residual SS (rSS) was measured during assessment of the actual operative report for each patient after CABG. Patients were then stratified according to tercile cut points of low (rSS low 0-11, N = 537), intermediate (rSS mid >11-18.5, N = 539) and high residual SS (rSS high >18.5, N = 532). The Cox regression model was used to investigate the impact of rSS on major adverse cardiac and cerebrovascular events (MACCE) at 1 year.
The mean preoperative SS was 26.6 (SD: 9.4) (range 10.1-53), and the residual SS after CABG was 15.3 (SD: 8.4) (range 0-34) ( P < 0.001 versus preoperative). At 1 year, cumulative incidence of MACCE in the low rSS was 1.5% ( N = 8/537), 4.5% ( N = 24/539) in the intermediate and 8.8% ( N = 47/532) in the high rSS group. Kaplan-Meier analysis showed a statistically significant difference of MACCE-free survival between the three groups (log-rank test, P < 0.001). The estimated MACCE-free survival rate at 1 year was 98.1% [standard error (SE): 1.6] for the rSS low , 95.5% (SE: 1.9) for the rSS mid , and 90.5% (SE: 1.3) for the rSS high group, respectively. After multivariable adjustment, the rSS high group was independently associated with a higher incidence of MACCE at 1 year (hazard ratio 1.92, 95% confidence interval 1.21-3.23) compared to the rSS low group.
These unanticipated findings suggest that a residual SS may be a useful tool for risk stratification of patients undergoing isolated first-time CABG. Our study may set the stage for further investigations addressing this important clinical question.
量化使用SYNTAX评分(SS)测量的残余冠状动脉疾病及其与冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG)后结局的关系。
我们对2004年至2015年连续1608例首次接受单纯CABG的患者[平均年龄68岁,标准差(SD):7,女性:男性,242:1366]进行了回顾性分析。术前SS通过术前血管造影回顾性确定,残余SS(rSS)在CABG后对每位患者的实际手术报告评估期间进行测量。然后根据低(rSS低0 - 11,N = 537)、中(rSS中>11 - 18.5,N = 539)和高残余SS(rSS高>18.5,N = 532)的三分位数切点对患者进行分层。使用Cox回归模型研究rSS对1年时主要不良心脑血管事件(MACCE)的影响。
术前平均SS为26.6(SD:9.4)(范围10.1 - 53),CABG后残余SS为15.3(SD:8.4)(范围0 - 34)(与术前相比,P < 0.001)。1年时,低rSS组MACCE的累积发生率为1.5%(N = 8/537),中rSS组为4.5%(N = 24/539),高rSS组为8.8%(N = 47/532)。Kaplan - Meier分析显示三组之间无MACCE生存存在统计学显著差异(对数秩检验,P < 0.001)。rSS低组1年时无MACCE生存率估计为98.1%[标准误(SE):1.6],rSS中组为95.5%(SE:1.9),rSS高组为90.5%(SE:1.3)。多变量调整后,与rSS低组相比,rSS高组在1年时独立与更高发生率的MACCE相关(风险比1.92,95%置信区间1.21 - 3.23)。
这些意外发现表明,残余SS可能是首次接受单纯CABG患者风险分层的有用工具。我们的研究可能为解决这一重要临床问题的进一步研究奠定基础。