Zhu N S, Ling Z H, Shen J, Lane J M, Hu S L
Bull World Health Organ. 1989;67(4):431-41.
The Cooperative Medical System (CMS) and its barefoot doctors have been in decline in rural China for nearly a decade. In order to explore the reasons for this, in 1987 we carried out a survey of villagers, barefoot doctors, and local administrators in Fengxian, Shanggoa, and Loaan counties, where incomes are good, fair, and low, respectively. The state of the CMS in these counties was contrasted and the situations which prevailed in 1978, 1982, and 1985, when the system was, respectively, at its peak, had begun to decline, and had declined markedly, were compared. A random sample of villages was selected and all the barefoot doctors and administrators as well as a random sample of households were surveyed. The results indicate that health status (as measured by infant mortality, immunization coverage, and rate of infectious diseases) has decreased in areas where the CMS has declined, while per capita incomes increased. Concomitantly, villager's expenditures on health care have increased. Barefoot doctors and their patients were, however, reasonably happy with the system, and in its absence the doctors are no longer able to obtain ongoing training. The CMS was fiscally sound, and did not decline to the same extent in all areas--it continues to thrive in Fengxian, which is relatively affluent. It is concluded that the system probably declined because many local administrators perceived that it no longer enjoyed the backing of the central government.
在中国农村,合作医疗制度(CMS)及其赤脚医生已衰退近十年。为探究其原因,1987年我们分别对奉贤、上高和洛安三县的村民、赤脚医生及当地管理人员进行了调查,这三个县的收入状况分别为良好、中等和较低。对比了这些县合作医疗制度的状况,并比较了该制度在1978年(处于巅峰)、1982年(开始衰退)和1985年(显著衰退)时的情况。我们随机抽取了一些村庄,对所有赤脚医生、管理人员以及随机抽取的一些家庭进行了调查。结果表明,在合作医疗制度衰退的地区,健康状况(以婴儿死亡率、免疫接种覆盖率和传染病发病率衡量)有所下降,而人均收入有所增加。与此同时,村民的医疗保健支出增加。然而,赤脚医生及其患者对该制度总体上比较满意,若没有该制度,医生无法获得持续培训。合作医疗制度在财政上是健全的,且并非在所有地区都衰退到相同程度——在相对富裕的奉贤县,该制度仍在蓬勃发展。研究得出结论,该制度衰退可能是因为许多地方管理人员认为它不再得到中央政府的支持。