Alsaied Tarek, Bokma Jouke P, Engel Mark E, Kuijpers Joey M, Hanke Samuel P, Zuhlke Liesl, Zhang Bin, Veldtman Gruschen R
Children's Heart Institute, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
Department of Cardiology, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Heart. 2017 Jan 15;103(2):104-110. doi: 10.1136/heartjnl-2016-310108. Epub 2016 Nov 9.
Despite an ageing Fontan population, data on late outcomes are still scarce. Reported outcome measures and determinants vary greatly between studies making comprehensive appraisal of mortality hazard challenging.
We conducted a systematic review to evaluate causes and factors associated with late mortality in patients with Fontan circulation. Late mortality was defined as mortality beyond the first postoperative year. Studies were included if they had ≥90 patients or ≥20 late mortalities and/or transplants. Studies with overlapping patients were rationalised to include only the most recent studies to avoid duplication.
From 28 studies, a total of 6707 patients with an average follow-up time of 8.23±5.42 years was identified. There were 1000 deaths. Causes of late death were reported in 697 cases. The five most common causes were heart/Fontan failure (22%), arrhythmia (16%), respiratory failure (15%), renal disease (12%) and thrombosis/bleeding (10%). Factors associated with late mortality were evaluated and classified into 9 categories.
Causes and factors associated with late mortality after the Fontan operation are summarised in this study. The presented information will aid in identifying patients at highest risk for mortality and guide our risk stratification efforts in this patient population.
尽管接受Fontan手术的患者群体在老龄化,但关于远期结局的数据仍然稀少。各研究报告的结局指标和决定因素差异很大,这使得对死亡风险进行全面评估具有挑战性。
我们进行了一项系统评价,以评估与Fontan循环患者远期死亡相关的原因和因素。远期死亡定义为术后第一年以后的死亡。如果研究纳入了≥90例患者或≥20例远期死亡病例和/或移植病例,则纳入该研究。对有重叠患者的研究进行了合理化处理,仅纳入最新的研究以避免重复。
从28项研究中,共确定了6707例患者,平均随访时间为8.23±5.42年。有1000例死亡。697例报告了远期死亡原因。最常见的五个原因是心脏/Fontan衰竭(22%)、心律失常(16%)、呼吸衰竭(15%)、肾脏疾病(12%)和血栓形成/出血(10%)。对与远期死亡相关的因素进行了评估,并分为9类。
本研究总结了Fontan手术后与远期死亡相关的原因和因素。所提供的信息将有助于识别死亡风险最高的患者,并指导我们对该患者群体进行风险分层的工作。