*Department of Family and Community Medicine,University of Toronto,Toronto,ON.
CJEM. 2018 Jan;20(1):148-153. doi: 10.1017/cem.2016.408. Epub 2017 Jan 9.
Collecting patient-reported follow-up data for prospective studies in the emergency department (ED) is challenging in this minimal continuity setting. The objective of this study was to determine whether text messaging study participants involved in an ongoing randomized trial resulted in a lower rate of attrition as compared to conventional telephone follow-up.
This was a nested cohort analysis of research participants enrolled in a randomized controlled trial assessing head injury discharge instructions. During the first 4 months of study follow-up, participants were contacted by a conventional telephone call. For the final 3 months, participants were contacted by text messaging following the first failed telephone attempt.
A total of 118 patients were enrolled in the study (78 underwent conventional follow-up, and 40 received text messages). During the period of conventional follow-up, 3 participants withdrew from the study. Of the remaining 75 participants, 24 (32.0%) at 2 weeks and 32 (42.7%) at 4 weeks were unable to be contacted. Of the 40 participants receiving a reminder text message, 4 (10.0%) at 2 weeks and 10 (25.0%) at 4 weeks were unable to be contacted. Overall, text messaging study participants decreased attrition by 22% (95% CI: 5.9%, 34.7%) and 17.7% (95% CI: -0.8%, 33.3%) at 2- and 4-week follow-ups, respectively.
In this ED cohort participating in a randomized trial, text message reminders of upcoming telephone follow-up interviews decreased the rate of attrition. Text messaging is a viable, low-cost communication strategy that can improve follow-up participation in prospective research studies.
在这种连续性极低的急诊环境中,收集前瞻性研究的患者报告随访数据具有挑战性。本研究的目的是确定与传统电话随访相比,通过短信与参与正在进行的随机试验的研究参与者联系是否会降低失访率。
这是一项嵌套队列分析,研究对象为参与评估头部损伤出院医嘱的随机对照试验的研究参与者。在研究随访的前 4 个月,参与者通过常规电话联系。在最后 3 个月,在首次电话尝试失败后,通过短信联系参与者。
共有 118 名患者入组该研究(78 名接受常规随访,40 名接受短信)。在常规随访期间,有 3 名参与者退出研究。在其余 75 名参与者中,有 24 名(32.0%)在 2 周时和 32 名(42.7%)在 4 周时无法联系。在收到提醒短信的 40 名参与者中,有 4 名(10.0%)在 2 周时和 10 名(25.0%)在 4 周时无法联系。总体而言,短信研究参与者将失访率分别降低了 22%(95%CI:5.9%,34.7%)和 17.7%(95%CI:-0.8%,33.3%),在 2 周和 4 周的随访中。
在参与随机试验的这个 ED 队列中,短信提醒即将进行电话随访访谈可降低失访率。短信是一种可行的、低成本的沟通策略,可以提高前瞻性研究的随访参与度。