McEwen Malcolm R, Taank Jaswinder
Ionizing Radiation Standards, National Research Council Canada, Ottawa, Canada.
Department of Medical Physics and Applied Radiation Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada.
Med Phys. 2017 Feb;44(2):694-702. doi: 10.1002/mp.12057. Epub 2017 Jan 30.
International dosimetry protocols require measurements made with a vented ionization chamber to be corrected for the influence of air density by using the standard temperature-pressure correction factor. The effect of humidity, on the other hand, is generally ignored with the provision that the relative humidity (RH) is within certain limits (typically 20% to 80%). However, there is little experimental data in the published literature as to the true effect of humidity on modern reference-class ionization chambers. This investigation used two different radiation beams - a Co-60 irradiator and an Sr-90 check source - to examine the effect of humidity on several Farmer-type ionization chambers.
An environmental cabinet controlled the humidity. For the Co-60 beam, the irradiation was external, whereas for the Sr-90 measurements, the source itself was placed within the cabinet. Extensive measurements were carried out to ensure that the experimental setup provided reproducible readings. Four chamber types were investigated: IBA FC65-G, IBA FC65-P, PTW 30013 and Exradin A19. The different wall materials provided potentially different mechanical responses (i.e., in terms of expansion/contraction) to the water content in the air. The relative humidity was varied between 8% and 98% and measurements were made with both increasing and decreasing humidity to investigate any possible hysteresis effects.
Measurements in Co-60 were consistent with the published data obtained with primary standard cavity chambers in ICRU Report 31 (i.e., a very small variation <0.1% for RH >10%). The measurements in the Sr-90 field showed no dependence with the relative humidity, within the measurement uncertainties (0.05%, k = 1). Very good repeatability of the ionization current was obtained over successive wet/dry cycles, no hysteresis was observed, and there was no dependence on chamber type.
These results indicate that humidity has no significant effect on these particular types of ionization chambers, consistent with recommendations in current megavoltage dosimetry protocols.
国际剂量测定协议要求,使用带通风孔的电离室进行测量时,需通过使用标准温度 - 压力校正因子来校正空气密度的影响。另一方面,通常在相对湿度(RH)处于一定范围内(通常为20%至80%)时忽略湿度的影响。然而,已发表的文献中几乎没有关于湿度对现代参考级电离室真实影响的实验数据。本研究使用两种不同的辐射束——一个钴 - 60辐照器和一个锶 - 90校验源——来研究湿度对几种 Farmer 型电离室的影响。
一个环境箱控制湿度。对于钴 - 60束,辐照是在外部进行的,而对于锶 - 90测量,源本身放置在箱内。进行了大量测量以确保实验装置能提供可重复的读数。研究了四种电离室类型:IBA FC65 - G、IBA FC65 - P、PTW 30013和Exradin A19。不同的壁材料对空气中的含水量可能有不同的机械响应(即,在膨胀/收缩方面)。相对湿度在8%至98%之间变化,并且在湿度增加和降低时都进行了测量,以研究任何可能的滞后效应。
钴 - 60的测量结果与ICRU报告31中使用原级标准空腔电离室获得的已发表数据一致(即,对于相对湿度>10%,变化非常小<0.1%)。在锶 - 90场中的测量结果表明,在测量不确定度(0.05%,k = 1)范围内,与相对湿度无关。在连续的湿/干循环中获得了电离电流非常好的重复性,未观察到滞后现象,并且与电离室类型无关。
这些结果表明,湿度对这些特定类型的电离室没有显著影响,这与当前兆伏级剂量测定协议中的建议一致。