Murray Brett, Kue Ricky
1Boston University School of Medicine,Boston,MassachusettsUSA.
Prehosp Disaster Med. 2017 Apr;32(2):209-216. doi: 10.1017/S1049023X16001503. Epub 2017 Jan 30.
The benefits of emergency lights and sirens (L&S) use as warning devices by ambulances continue to be a debated topic in Emergency Medical Services (EMS). While the most widely studied aspect of L&S use has been related to their effect on ambulance response and transport times, the literature suggests minimal time savings with more questionable impact on actual patient outcomes. As L&S use has been shown to increase the risk for vehicle crashes, the secondary concern of ambulance design and safety also becomes an important aspect on potential design recommendations that could mitigate the effects of a crash on patients, EMS providers, and the general public. The least studied aspect of L&S use (and probably the most important) is their effect on patient outcomes and quality of medical care during transport. The current evidence suggests no significant improvement on patient outcomes and potential worsening to certain aspects of patient care during transport. The purpose of this review was to examine the current literature regarding ambulance L&S use and the risks they pose to EMS providers, patients, and the general public. In doing so, it will provide sound background for EMS leaders to better develop policies governing the use of L&S by ambulances and promote better research in the patient outcomes effect associated with their use. This review offers some strategies in mitigating the risks associated with L&S use, such as ways to reduce their overall use and modifying other related factors to emergency medical vehicle collisions (EMVCs). Murray B , Kue R . The use of emergency lights and sirens by ambulances and their effect on patient outcomes and public safety: a comprehensive review of the literature. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2017;32(2):209-216.
救护车使用应急灯和警报器作为警示装置的益处,在紧急医疗服务(EMS)领域仍然是一个备受争议的话题。虽然对应急灯和警报器使用的研究最为广泛的方面是其对救护车响应和运输时间的影响,但文献表明节省的时间极少,对实际患者预后的影响也更值得怀疑。由于已证明使用应急灯和警报器会增加车辆碰撞的风险,救护车设计与安全的次要问题也成为潜在设计建议的一个重要方面,这些建议可能会减轻碰撞对患者、EMS提供者和公众的影响。应急灯和警报器使用方面研究最少的(可能也是最重要的)是它们在运输过程中对患者预后和医疗护理质量的影响。目前的证据表明,对患者预后没有显著改善,而且在运输过程中可能会使患者护理的某些方面恶化;本综述的目的是研究当前关于救护车使用应急灯和警报器以及它们给EMS提供者、患者和公众带来的风险的文献。这样做将为EMS领导者更好地制定管理救护车使用应急灯和警报器的政策,并促进对与其使用相关的患者预后影响进行更好的研究提供可靠的背景。本综述提供了一些减轻与使用应急灯和警报器相关风险的策略,例如减少其总体使用的方法以及改变与紧急医疗车辆碰撞(EMVC)相关的其他因素。默里·B、库埃·R。救护车应急灯和警报器的使用及其对患者预后和公共安全的影响:文献综述。院前灾难医学。201年;32(2):209 - 216。