Pham Thuy T, Moore Steven T, Lewis Simon John Geoffrey, Nguyen Diep N, Dutkiewicz Eryk, Fuglevand Andrew J, McEwan Alistair L, Leong Philip H W
School of Computing and Communications, University of Technology Sydney, Ultimo, NSW, Australia.
Human Aerospace Laboratory, Neurology Department, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai.
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2017 Nov;64(11):2719-2728. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2017.2665438.
Freezing of gait (FoG) is common in Parkinsonian gait and strongly relates to falls. Current clinical FoG assessments are patients' self-report diaries and experts' manual video analysis. Both are subjective and yield moderate reliability. Existing detection algorithms have been predominantly designed in subject-dependent settings. In this paper, we aim to develop an automated FoG detector for subject independent. After extracting highly relevant features, we apply anomaly detection techniques to detect FoG events. Specifically, feature selection is performed using correlation and clusterability metrics. From a list of 244 feature candidates, 36 candidates were selected using saliency and robustness criteria. We develop an anomaly score detector with adaptive thresholding to identify FoG events. Then, using accuracy metrics, we reduce the feature list to seven candidates. Our novel multichannel freezing index was the most selective across all window sizes, achieving sensitivity (specificity) of (). On the other hand, freezing index from the vertical axis was the best choice for a single input, achieving sensitivity (specificity) of () for ankle and () for back sensors. Our subject-independent method is not only significantly more accurate than those previously reported, but also uses a much smaller window (e.g., versus ) and/or lower tolerance (e.g., versus ).Freezing of gait (FoG) is common in Parkinsonian gait and strongly relates to falls. Current clinical FoG assessments are patients' self-report diaries and experts' manual video analysis. Both are subjective and yield moderate reliability. Existing detection algorithms have been predominantly designed in subject-dependent settings. In this paper, we aim to develop an automated FoG detector for subject independent. After extracting highly relevant features, we apply anomaly detection techniques to detect FoG events. Specifically, feature selection is performed using correlation and clusterability metrics. From a list of 244 feature candidates, 36 candidates were selected using saliency and robustness criteria. We develop an anomaly score detector with adaptive thresholding to identify FoG events. Then, using accuracy metrics, we reduce the feature list to seven candidates. Our novel multichannel freezing index was the most selective across all window sizes, achieving sensitivity (specificity) of (). On the other hand, freezing index from the vertical axis was the best choice for a single input, achieving sensitivity (specificity) of () for ankle and () for back sensors. Our subject-independent method is not only significantly more accurate than those previously reported, but also uses a much smaller window (e.g., versus ) and/or lower tolerance (e.g., versus ).
冻结步态(FoG)在帕金森步态中很常见,且与跌倒密切相关。目前临床对冻结步态的评估是患者的自我报告日记和专家的手动视频分析。这两种方法都具有主观性,可靠性一般。现有的检测算法主要是在依赖个体的设置中设计的。在本文中,我们旨在开发一种独立于个体的自动冻结步态检测器。在提取高度相关的特征后,我们应用异常检测技术来检测冻结步态事件。具体来说,使用相关性和可聚类性指标进行特征选择。从244个候选特征列表中,根据显著性和稳健性标准选择了36个候选特征。我们开发了一种具有自适应阈值的异常分数检测器来识别冻结步态事件。然后,使用准确性指标,我们将特征列表减少到7个候选特征。我们新颖的多通道冻结指数在所有窗口大小中选择性最高,实现了()的灵敏度(特异性)。另一方面,垂直轴的冻结指数是单一输入的最佳选择,脚踝传感器的灵敏度(特异性)为(),背部传感器的灵敏度(特异性)为()。我们独立于个体的方法不仅比先前报道的方法显著更准确,而且使用的窗口要小得多(例如,与相比)和/或容忍度更低(例如,与相比)。冻结步态(FoG)在帕金森步态中很常见,且与跌倒密切相关。目前临床对冻结步态的评估是患者的自我报告日记和专家的手动视频分析。这两种方法都具有主观性,可靠性一般。现有的检测算法主要是在依赖个体的设置中设计的。在本文中,我们旨在开发一种独立于个体的自动冻结步态检测器。在提取高度相关的特征后,我们应用异常检测技术来检测冻结步态事件。具体来说,使用相关性和可聚类性指标进行特征选择。从244个候选特征列表中,根据显著性和稳健性标准选择了36个候选特征。我们开发了一种具有自适应阈值的异常分数检测器来识别冻结步态事件。然后,使用准确性指标,我们将特征列表减少到7个候选特征。我们新颖的多通道冻结指数在所有窗口大小中选择性最高,实现了()的灵敏度(特异性)。另一方面,垂直轴的冻结指数是单一输入的最佳选择,脚踝传感器的灵敏度(特异性)为(),背部传感器的灵敏度(特异性)为()。我们独立于个体的方法不仅比先前报道的方法显著更准确,而且使用的窗口要小得多(例如,与相比)和/或容忍度更低(例如,与相比)。