Mitchell Karen S, Wolf Erika J, Bovin Michelle J, Lee Lewina O, Green Jonathan D, Rosen Raymond C, Keane Terence M, Marx Brian P
National Center for PTSD, VA Boston Healthcare System.
VA Boston Healthcare System, Research Service.
J Abnorm Psychol. 2017 Apr;126(3):355-366. doi: 10.1037/abn0000252. Epub 2017 Feb 13.
Recent proposals for revisions to the 11th edition of the () posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) diagnostic criteria have argued that the current symptom constellation under the is unwieldy and includes many symptoms that overlap with other disorders. The newly proposed criteria for the include only 6 symptoms. However, restricting the symptoms to those included in the has implications for PTSD diagnosis prevalence estimates, and it remains unclear whether these 6 symptoms are most strongly associated with a diagnosis of PTSD. Network analytic methods, which assume that psychiatric disorders are networks of interrelated symptoms, provide information regarding which symptoms are most central to a network. We estimated network models of PTSD in a national sample of veterans of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. In the full sample, the most central symptoms were persistent negative emotional state, efforts to avoid external reminders, efforts to avoid thoughts or memories, inability to experience positive emotions, distressing dreams, and intrusive distressing thoughts or memories; that is, 3 of the 6 most central items to the network would be eliminated from the diagnosis under the current proposal for . An empirically defined index summarizing the most central symptoms in the network performed comparably to an index reflecting the proposed PTSD criteria at identifying individuals with an independently assessed DSM-5 defined PTSD diagnosis. Our results highlight the symptoms most central to PTSD in this sample, which may inform future diagnostic systems and treatment. (PsycINFO Database Record
近期对《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》()第11版创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)诊断标准修订的提议认为,当前该手册下的症状组合繁杂,且包含许多与其他障碍重叠的症状。新提议的该手册标准仅包含6种症状。然而,将症状限制在手册所涵盖的范围内,会对PTSD诊断患病率估计产生影响,目前尚不清楚这6种症状是否与PTSD诊断关联最为紧密。网络分析方法假定精神障碍是相互关联症状的网络,能提供有关哪些症状对网络最为核心的信息。我们在伊拉克和阿富汗战争退伍军人的全国样本中估计了PTSD的网络模型。在整个样本中,最核心的症状是持续的负性情绪状态、努力避免外部提醒、努力避免想法或记忆、无法体验积极情绪、痛苦的梦境以及侵入性痛苦想法或记忆;也就是说,根据当前对手册的提议,网络中6个最核心项目中的3个将从诊断中剔除。一个根据经验定义的总结网络中最核心症状的指标,在识别经独立评估符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第5版定义的PTSD诊断的个体时,与反映提议的PTSD标准的指标表现相当。我们的结果突出了该样本中对PTSD最核心的症状,这可能为未来的诊断系统和治疗提供参考。(《心理学文摘数据库记录》