Treece Graham
University of Cambridge, Department of Engineering, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 1PZ, UK.
Comput Med Imaging Graph. 2017 Mar;56:11-23. doi: 10.1016/j.compmedimag.2017.01.005. Epub 2017 Feb 1.
X-ray computed tomography (CT) data contains artefacts from many sources, with sufficient prominence to affect diagnostic utility when metal is present in the scans. These artefacts can be reduced, usually by the removal and in-filling of any sinogram data which has been affected by metal, and several such techniques have been proposed. Most of them are prone to introducing new artefacts into the CT data or may take a long time to correct the data. It is the purpose of this paper to introduce a new technique which is fast, yet can effectively remove most artefacts without introducing significant new ones. The new metal artefact reduction technique (RMAR) consists of an iterative refinement of the CT data by alternately forward- and back-projecting the part of the reconstruction near to metal. The forward-projection is corrected by making use of a prior derived from the reconstructed data which is independently estimated for each projection angle, and smoothed using a newly developed Bitonic filter. The new technique is compared with previously published (LI, NMAR, MDT) and commercial (O-MAR, IMAR) alternatives, quantitatively on phantom data, and qualitatively on a selection of clinical scans, mostly of the hip. The phantom data is from two recently published studies, enabling direct comparison with previous results. The results show an increased reduction of artefacts on the four phantom data sets tested. On two of the phantom data sets, RMAR is significantly better (p<0.001) than all other techniques; on one it is as good as any other technique, and on the last it is only beaten by the Metal Deletion Technique (p<0.001), which is significantly slower. On the clinical data sets, RMAR shows visually similar performance to MDT, with better preservation of bony features close to metal implants, but perhaps slightly reduced homogeneity in the far field. For typical CT data, RMAR can correct each image in 3-8s, which is more than one hundred times faster than MDT. The new technique is demonstrated to have performance at least as good as MDT, with both out-performing other approaches. However, it is much faster then the latter technique, and shows better preservation of data very close to metal.
X射线计算机断层扫描(CT)数据包含来自多种来源的伪影,当扫描中存在金属时,这些伪影的显著程度足以影响诊断效用。这些伪影通常可以通过去除和填充受金属影响的任何正弦图数据来减少,并且已经提出了几种这样的技术。它们中的大多数容易在CT数据中引入新的伪影,或者可能需要很长时间来校正数据。本文的目的是介绍一种新技术,该技术速度快,并且能够有效去除大多数伪影而不会引入大量新的伪影。新的金属伪影减少技术(RMAR)包括通过交替地对靠近金属的重建部分进行前向和后向投影来对CT数据进行迭代细化。前向投影通过利用从重建数据导出的先验进行校正,该先验针对每个投影角度独立估计,并使用新开发的双调谐滤波器进行平滑处理。新技术与先前发表的(LI、NMAR、MDT)和商业(O-MAR、IMAR)替代方法进行了比较,在体模数据上进行了定量比较,在一系列临床扫描(主要是髋关节扫描)上进行了定性比较。体模数据来自最近发表的两项研究,能够与先前的结果进行直接比较。结果表明,在测试的四个体模数据集上,伪影减少量有所增加。在其中两个体模数据集上,RMAR明显优于所有其他技术(p<0.001);在一个数据集上,它与任何其他技术一样好,在最后一个数据集上,它仅被金属删除技术击败(p<0.001),而金属删除技术明显更慢。在临床数据集上,RMAR在视觉上显示出与MDT相似的性能,在靠近金属植入物的骨特征方面有更好的保留,但在远场中均匀性可能略有降低。对于典型的CT数据,RMAR可以在3-8秒内校正每个图像,这比MDT快一百多倍。新技术被证明具有至少与MDT一样好的性能,两者都优于其他方法。然而,它比后一种技术快得多,并且在非常靠近金属的数据保存方面表现更好。